Xeprerys, those are some very interesting points. I'm sure that when SCOTUS sees any statutes of this nature, they are going to look at exactly what you've outlined. Given the current makeup of the court, you might well be right on all of these point.
Your last point isn't valid, though. Wishing someone dead isn't illegal, even if you say it about the President. Saying that you're the one who is going to do it is another story altogether, but wishing someone dead is completely within your rights. It is not illegal, nor should it be. It is an expression of belief, similar to saying that you wished someone would not participate in a discussion. Where do you draw the line?
|