Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community - View Single Post - Half Blood Prince Question/theory (spoilers)

Yakk · 01-27-2006, 12:41 PM

Spoiler: a> Snape killed Dumbledore because Snape is more important than Dumbledore. By killing DD, Snape has proven himself beyond any doubt to Voldy. Snape, opposed to Voldy[1], can now get information on where the horocrux's are.

b> Harry needs to learn occumancy because until he can block Voldy out of his mind, nobody can tell him Snape is on the good guys side. Snape hates Harry[2], but is still a good guy.

c> DD is dead. Really.

d> Harry should be the final Horocrux for a number of reasons. First, it explains alot of the events of the books better than the half-assed explainations in the books (try to use a death curse on your own soul container, and things go wonkey). Second, Voldy killed Lily and James and was killing Harry when Lily's "love magic" screwed him up. Odds are he wouldn't waste a personal killing without making yet another horocrux -- I suspect the screw up caused a piece of Voldy's soul to get hooked on Harry. Third, it provides a dark and tragic ending of self-sacrafice, and absolves her of writing more Harry Potter stories.

Footnote:
[1] Spoiler: Snape loved Lily. Voldy killed Lily. Snape will kill Voldy for this act.

[2] Spoiler: Harry has the eyes of his true love (Lily) staring out from the face of his bitter foe (James). How could Snape not hate Harry?

01-27-2006, 12:41 PM	#36 (permalink)
Yakk Wehret Den Anfängen! Location: Ontario, Canada	Spoiler: a> Snape killed Dumbledore because Snape is more important than Dumbledore. By killing DD, Snape has proven himself beyond any doubt to Voldy. Snape, opposed to Voldy[1], can now get information on where the horocrux's are. b> Harry needs to learn occumancy because until he can block Voldy out of his mind, nobody can tell him Snape is on the good guys side. Snape hates Harry[2], but is still a good guy. c> DD is dead. Really. d> Harry should be the final Horocrux for a number of reasons. First, it explains alot of the events of the books better than the half-assed explainations in the books (try to use a death curse on your own soul container, and things go wonkey). Second, Voldy killed Lily and James and was killing Harry when Lily's "love magic" screwed him up. Odds are he wouldn't waste a personal killing without making yet another horocrux -- I suspect the screw up caused a piece of Voldy's soul to get hooked on Harry. Third, it provides a dark and tragic ending of self-sacrafice, and absolves her of writing more Harry Potter stories. Footnote: [1] Spoiler: Snape loved Lily. Voldy killed Lily. Snape will kill Voldy for this act. [2] Spoiler: Harry has the eyes of his true love (Lily) staring out from the face of his bitter foe (James). How could Snape not hate Harry? __________________ Last edited by JHVH : 10-29-4004 BC at 09:00 PM. Reason: Time for a rest.