Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community - View Single Post

lurkette · 05-05-2005, 05:19 AM

Actually, the article said he was almost in a persistent vegetative state.

I hesitate to even bring this issue up again but the deal with Terri Schiavo was that there was essentially NO BRAIN LEFT for the drugs to work on. The part of the brain that handles higher functions like speech and cognition was just GONE, and even some of her brainstem functions (like swallowing) were gone. Essentially replaced by CS fluid. Lack of oxygen doesn't always have the same effect on people's brains, and clearly this guy had enough brain to sit up on his own in a wheelchair and, eventually, speak. Terri Schiavo had little non-reflexive motor capacity, and the parts of the brain that control speech were, as I've said, gone. Not just "nonfunctional" - GONE. Liquefied. This sounds like a COMPLETELY different situation, and just because the two cases have words in common like "coma" and "almost in a persistent vegetative state," don't go thinking that gosh, they pulled the plug too soon on Terri Schiavo.

I'm thrilled that this treatment worked for this man - it must be terrifying to know that you've missed almost a decade of your life, and your family's lives, but how gratifying would it be for that family to finally have you back? They have some hard going ahead of them, with medical therapy and all the adjustments they'll need to make. None of them are going to be the same people the other remembers from 10 years ago. I wish them well.

05-05-2005, 05:19 AM	#3 (permalink)
lurkette My future is coming on Moderator Emeritus Location: east of the sun and west of the moon	Actually, the article said he was almost in a persistent vegetative state. I hesitate to even bring this issue up again but the deal with Terri Schiavo was that there was essentially NO BRAIN LEFT for the drugs to work on. The part of the brain that handles higher functions like speech and cognition was just GONE, and even some of her brainstem functions (like swallowing) were gone. Essentially replaced by CS fluid. Lack of oxygen doesn't always have the same effect on people's brains, and clearly this guy had enough brain to sit up on his own in a wheelchair and, eventually, speak. Terri Schiavo had little non-reflexive motor capacity, and the parts of the brain that control speech were, as I've said, gone. Not just "nonfunctional" - GONE. Liquefied. This sounds like a COMPLETELY different situation, and just because the two cases have words in common like "coma" and "almost in a persistent vegetative state," don't go thinking that gosh, they pulled the plug too soon on Terri Schiavo. I'm thrilled that this treatment worked for this man - it must be terrifying to know that you've missed almost a decade of your life, and your family's lives, but how gratifying would it be for that family to finally have you back? They have some hard going ahead of them, with medical therapy and all the adjustments they'll need to make. None of them are going to be the same people the other remembers from 10 years ago. I wish them well. __________________ "If ten million people believe a foolish thing, it is still a foolish thing." - Anatole France Last edited by lurkette; 05-05-2005 at 05:21 AM..