This guy sounds fundamentally selfish to me, Seeker, and the girl overly critical. Maybe they were made for each other
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d6b75/d6b75c3747d3b8a0f92408af1485908d433ae864" alt="Smilie"
Sounds like they need you more than you need them, perhaps as a way for them to validate their relationship. Whether their relationship is "proper" or not is not for me to judge, of course--but I don't think they should make that your problem either.