Yakk

Dancr, you are attempting to define the middle away. I don't see the usefulness of this.

There is a simple, natural, 4 way split:
A: There are people who are convinced in the existance of a God.
-A: There are people who are convinced in the non-existance of a God.
~A: There are people who are not convinced in the existance of a God.
~-A: There are peope who are not convinced in the non-existance of a God.

It is pretty clear that "A" are theists.
It is pretty clear that "-A" are atheists.

You seem to want to place "~A" into the atheist label as well.

On top of this, we have the fact that in reality the middle is never excluded.

#A: There are people who are somewhat convinced in the existance of a God.
and
@A: There are people who are convinced in the somewhat existance of a God.

which leaves us with, at the very least:
A -A ~A #A @A
-~A -#A -@A ~#A ~@A #@A
-~#A -~@A ~#@A
-~#@A

if you assume order doesn't matter. I assume I missed something. =)

(edit: added a 15th)

__________________
Last edited by JHVH : 10-29-4004 BC at 09:00 PM. Reason: Time for a rest.