Quote:
|
Originally Posted by GMontag
As I don't have a copy of the book, and most of those responses are one-liner "see my book on page blah", I can't verify them. But I did notice that he doesn't even *try* to refute the fact that he misidentified basic data such as when laws were changed. Mistakes at that level throw the whole study into suspicion
|
As you "don't have a copy of the book", I'm not sure then why you sieze upon the first thing you saw on the HCI website (which was not even substantiated) to discredit the work without even making an effort to read any of the critiques and responses.
If you want to discredit it, you might at least go to the last link I provided. There seems to be some interesting points against it even if I don't agree with them.