Doom3 deinfatly. I held the stupid flashlight more than I held a gun!
It would have been fine if you could have the flashlight on while holding a gun like you can in HalfLife. You would still have the moodiness of things being dark but you could see what you're shooting at. Even having a weapon like the shotgun have a flashlight attached would have worked. We have guns like that NOW... why not in the future?!
Also, having the monsters hiding behind paneling in the walls that open up when you're around?! That's just stupid. It was fine for a game 10 years ago, but if you're going for realism it just doesn't work!
What a let down. If I were a game developer I would go with HalfLife 2's engine rather than Doom 3's.
|