I actually liked both games, I think they were both over hyped, but that comes with the territory. doom 3 felt like a doom game, a lot of shooting a little story line, and a mostly linear game with little secrets sprinkled around. Half life 2 also felt like its predecessor beautiful environments with puzzles that arent too hard to solve for a seasoned gamer. I rate them fairly equal, but they both excelled in some areas and failed in others, they both had entertainment value, and that's what matters most to me.
|