Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Manx
Nonsense.
|
Hey Manx, thanks for your thoughtful and insightful post!
As I stated in my original post, show me don't tell me. I don't want to hear "nonsense" followed by nothing. What purpose does that serve? Answer: "nothing"
Let me try over:
I am telling you that your argument is false. I have posted the numbers to back up my claim.
Spouting out that "families will get hurt", the "poor will bear the burden" etc., are examples of the many, many points of opposition to this type of plan. You are not the first to see this, every redistributionist in the country says the same exact thing. Why? Because it goes against their beliefs. The problem is that they are bullet points and talking points without anything to back them up. I would be more than happy to post links to some of my information (not all of it is online), but it would be a very, very long post, with nothing but links. Nobody would bother to read it as it represents hundreds and hundres of pages of reading.
If a specific point is being refuted, I will post where I got the information (if it is possible) along with page numbers and paragraph numbers so that the information could viewed easily.
Anyway, your post was not accurate, in my opinion. If you have something more to add than "nonsense" I would love to discuss it. As I mentioned earlier, I would love to hear thoughtful opposition to this proposal. I do not want to hear regurgiatation of fear tactics that are based on nothing.
If there is real points of contention to this proposal, I want to discuss them and have asked to.