Quote:
Originally Posted by zen_tom
Ok, if you are referring to who I am in my post - I am me, the original me that stepped into the box. Despite claims to the contrary, a copy and the original are NOT the same thing. They may be equivalent from the outside, but the I that inhabits this mind would cease to be were my mind destroyed and re-created elsewhere.
If you took two slugs (slugs have very simple nervous-systems) and put them in the machine, one of the slugs would end and another one would be created. They might be thinking the same thing, but they're still two different slugs.
|
If you take a person and one by one replaced all the atoms in his or her body with an identical atom, would he or she be a different person? You seem to be claiming yes, but (as was mentioned earlier in the thread) this happens to everybody all the time. The figure I've heard is 7 years for a complete replacement of all the atoms in your body. So, are you not yourself after 7 years?