Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Beatlefan58
So you would have put one of them number 1 and the other at number 2? That's fine, seeding here is subjective, but let's not forget that if you did that, you'd have ONE of them facing facing REVOLVER, RUBBER SOUL or SGT. PEPPER either this round or next, and if next, two of those three facing off this time. Folks would complain about that, too.
Let's keep in mind that the object here is to determine the winner; just like the NCAA basketball tournament in the US or virtually any other sports event, the two best teams could meet in the semis or quarterfinals. The desired result is to have the two best square off in the finals, but that's not always the way it works.
Despite the "travesty" I made of this, I hope you're enjoying it!  |
Yes, it's all subjective. I would've ranked them much differently, but then again, I'm not in the "Sgt. Pepper is the best album ever" camp. I don't even think it's the best Beatles' album. Then again, I don't think Revolver is either, as you clearly do. It's all for fun, so no harm, no foul