Originally Posted by fhqwhgads

Another one I thought of:

I live on the East Coast of the US, and I went to Alaska a few years ago. I was wearing a shirt from my church, and someone on the cruise stopped me. Turns out that he lived right around the corner from my church. That's not the freaky part...

About a year or so later I had applied for a job. The guy calls me on the phone to set up my interview time, and he's chatting briefly about my employment packet. He noticed that I listed my involvment with the church youth group on my application. He proceeds to tell me how he lives right around the corner from my church. I reply with "You didn't happen to go on a cruise to Alaska a year or so ago, did you"? Same guy.