Seagate is the way to go, I've had a few over the last 3 years with no problem, but a few with a western digital HD including an issue that was solved only by wiping it. There is a reason that Seagate has a five year warranty while most of the others (WD and Maxtors) have only one to three. Plus, I've found that Seagate HD's run nearly silent and much cooler than their counterparts.
The comments on NewEgg's site about Seagate's 200 Gig version are very positive, its recieved 5 of 5 (
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProduc...148-032&depa=0)