Secret Method -- I think we actually agree, it's just that our emphases are somewhat different. I was discussing this with roommates and a friend last night, and that's the conclusion we came to. A Calvinist upbringing will affect one! Just for the record, the group was four graduate students at the most important Catholic university in the US (Go Fighting Irish!

), two of whom are theology students (there's a very thin line between a ninth year theology student and a PhD, mostly consisting of three letters). The joys of source comparison...