TFP vs IGN

[WhoaitsZ]

okay, I was in the doctor's office for about four hours. got slightly bored. thought of this, hope it works:

As in all lists of "the best" or what not we see options that make us go 'uhh no, that needs to be off the list!'. so i figured, why not post all 100 games and let the users vote for one game in a one day period. the voted game is removed and then go another round... untill we have one winner. this will take a very long time, but I want to do it bad. and i realize we'll run into several bumps and some people will miss their chance to vote. it's okay! we'll fix it somehow! just try and play along!

i would be thrilled to log on later and see this in motion. make it happen, please!

For the sake of it being cluttered, maybe we should do another thread concenring instructions and/or suggestions for this one. there will be tons of posts, i hope, stating why they voted this game off, and if we have suggestions and such at the same time it'll become outrageously difficult to read.

please vote! make this happen!

oh, here. a couple of ground rules...

Ground rules:

All 100 of the games are great and is someone's baby! No trash talking the games! A paragraph or a simple "I just don't like it because..". I'd hate to see the games get flamed!

Make the thread better. I'll create a secondary one for suggesions on how to do this as a fun and group effort.

Once you vote, it's over.

If you missed your chance to vote, sorry, but it's too late. You can still express your opinions and, who knows, we may do another poll after we finish this for the almosts and maybes.



Have fun!

ps: this is my first poll, so bear with me!

[WhoaitsZ]

damnit, i deleted my post.

i love almost all of these games, but...

simcity was dull but it was essential to some games i enjoy today. as was Ultima, and Adventure. two games I never played but are important.

I've never liked flight sims, though.. except for Top Gun and After Burner... so... AotP has to go!

[juanvaldes]

Aces of the Pacific - I don't like flight sims.

[Mr.Deflok]

I'm sorry, I can't decide!!

[WhoaitsZ]

Originally posted by Mr.Deflok
I'm sorry, I can't decide!!

no problem!!

come on fellas....... vote already... i've come up with a couple of changes i'll mention tomorrow so this poll will make more sense. i waaaaay overcomplicated the poll.

anyhow, POST and vote (unless you are undecided)
.... at least vote?

[Strelich]

Oddly I'm in the minority of old school sim freaks here, so I'm in the camp where AOTP simply cannot go. I'm also in the minority that I barely play console games and as such, am not a good candidate for knowing the wheat versus the chaff.

So, more or less like throwing darts, I'd axe Golden Axe. Uninformed, yes, but SimCity and AOTP would likely be in the top 20 if it were exclusive to a top 100 PC Games list.