Not when I do it to myself, but when someone else pokes my belly button, I get an odd feeling in my whatnot.

Not much of a feeling, but certainly something there. I wouldn't quite call it "feeling my penis from the inside" though!

I'm an innie and am, well, a little overweight...

I had to press my finger in quite hard to get anything, and now I must away to wash my finger - it stinks! Thanks... ;)

Yes for my wife and no for me....

the only 'funny sensation' i get in my bathing suit is when i pitch a tent

Yes, and it hurts. I've always hated that...

I don't get the belly button thing, but if I rub something soft over certain parts of my arm, I get a strange feeling on the bottom of my tounge. I also get the same thing walking barefoot in the sand occasionally as well. I suppose it would be cooler if it were in the "Bathing Suit Area."

I get the feeling. It might have something to do with being an "innie"....maybe?

Well i have you all beat not only do i feel it (however as i am fingering it and reading the post it is not as intense as when i was younger), i also have another one for you, 2 nights ago i was hanging out with some friends and i had thie chick i know trying to tickly me while i sat there and tried my damnedest to resist and i was fine till she startign doing this strange menuver right over and around my belly button, i got the very same squirmy feeling (the same as the belly button poking one but MUCH stronger and very widespread) from my belley button to my penis. So there i sit laughing my ass off cause i had never been ticked soooo badly before in my life (and i have had some brutal tickelings) and trying my damnedest not to get a fuckign hard on cause this is better but slower than any handjob i ever got. Or am i just a perv who loves being tickled by beutiful women? On this note for thoose of yo who are goign to be attemting belly button forplay, just spend a night tring not to laugh while your partner does everythign they can to tickly you, the motion was a strange dragging in curves and waves, btu once she got tequnique down nothing will stop you from laughing and feeling absolutly devine