![]() |
health & safety... where do you draw the line?
Its pretty ridiculous that men of the calibre of Knox-Johnson and Fiennes are made to light a stove under supervision...
But what really got me was making them take guidance on Polar exploration before they were allowed to set off Unless you somehow can channel the ghost of Amundsen, who exactly knows more about Polar conditions and is qualified to teach a lesson to Ranulph Fiennes?? Of course workers need protection... but surely its gone too far when men who have done more than any possible instrutor could have done are forced to take training courses? imagine the poor fuckers who were roped in to show Knox-Johnston how to sail a boat or Fiennes how to survive in the Arctic..... Quote:
|
90% of health and safety regs today are people covering their own asses.
|
Workers should be educated about potential risks of their environment and employers should be required to take reasonable precautions to protect employees. Let's make an example of something risky. A welder should be required to wear skin, face, and eye protection by the employer, and should be warned to ensure that all surfaces are clean and dry before welding (the average person, even the average welder, probably does not know that a welding torch will decompose chlorinated brake cleaner into hydrogen chloride and phosgene gases.) Even though anyone who is a certified welder should know it, they should be told that they are required to use ventilation equipment, and a respirator if appropriate to avoid metal fume fever. It is not necessary to warn a welder that a welding torch can cause third degree burns, that it should not be left burning unattended, that it should not be used to light cigarettes (seriously, the guy who did the exhaust on my old car did this as well as aiming, covering his eyes with his arm, and welding for a few seconds before checking his work instead of getting a mask,) and that it will be hot after it is extinguished. Safety equipment or reimbursement for it should be provided by the employer.
The UK has a reputation for being a nanny state because of the regulations you're mentioning. Also for things like banning the sale of steak knives and pizza cutters to minors, banning goggles in swimming classes, and recommendations that fire extinguishers be removed from common rooms in apartment buildings because they are a safety hazard (although that was from the Daily Mail and I'm not so sure about their credibility, they seem like a tabloid.) There is a fear of giving people responsibility or holding them responsible for their actions, and I feel that it is creating a society that is afraid to evaluate risks and whether they can be taken. |
I was until a couple of years ago the Health and Safety manager of a print works, and so am qualified and experienced in this area.
I also, as part of keeping up to date in the field I had to read the various digests and publications detailing H&S cases that had been prosecuted, and also listed the misguided attempts to ban things for reasons of "Health and Safety". The key thing to be aware of, is that the vast majority of people who bring this sort of stuff up are not law makers, but are petty jobs-worths are gold-plating well intentioned rules "just in case". All the storied about "conkers banned by health and safety nazis" and so on are bollocks. None of these were based on good solid legal advice, they are based on someone being scared of litigation. All Health and Safety law in the UK is based on the test of "reasonable practicability". In essence, this means that provided what you did will convince over half of a jury that you acted with good intentions, you are not breaking the law. |
Ranulph Fiennes is an amazing man. In 2003 he ran a marathon a day for 7 consecutive days, each on a different continent. That feat was performed 4 months following a heart attack and double bypass surgery.
Seriously, I think these guys could have 'survived' on their own. However, risk management is now a major consideration in every industry. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:22 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2
© 2002-2012 Tilted Forum Project