Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community

Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community (https://thetfp.com/tfp/)
-   General Discussion (https://thetfp.com/tfp/general-discussion/)
-   -   Olympic Controversy - Spanish Team in Offensive Photo (https://thetfp.com/tfp/general-discussion/138989-olympic-controversy-spanish-team-offensive-photo.html)

jorgelito 08-12-2008 05:46 PM

Olympic Controversy - Spanish Team in Offensive Photo
 
1 Attachment(s)
Wow, so I guess it was bound to happen. The Spanish Men's Basketball Team decided it would be fun to insult their Chinese hosts by taking a team photo with "Chinky eyes". What's even more shocking is the fact that they don't understand why this is insulting and don't think they did anything wrong. Really, this is pretty ridiculous and uncalled for. It's so American grade school I never thought liberal enlightened Europeans would stoop this low and resort to this type of debasement.

Spanish basketball team poses for offensive picture - Fourth-Place Medal - Olympics - Yahoo! Sports

Quote:

Spanish basketball team poses for offensive picture

By Chris Chase

Spain's Olympic basketball team posed for an advertisement prior to the Games which appears to show all its players slanting their eyes, a move that could offend its Olympic hosts in Beijing. The ads, for a Spanish courier company, appeared in the Spanish-language newspaper La Marca.

As the uproar over the picture has grown today, more information about the advertising shot has come to light. The New York Times reports that Spain's basketball team is sponsored by Li-Ning Footwear, a Chinese company founded by Li Ning, the final torchbearer who was hoisted along the top of Beijing National Stadium during the Olympic Opening Ceremony finale. The ad reportedly references the Spanish team recently extending their contract with the footwear giant for another four years.

The Spanish-language paper El Mundo has a piece debating whether the ad was racist that basically calls out the British press for trying to smear Spain's good name. But they miss the point. Whether the picture was made in good fun is irrelevant. It was a ridiculous idea that was bound to upset a lot of people.
It's baffling that nobody involved in the picture -- from the photographers to the players -- even seemed to consider that this ad would be looked at negatively. Did it not occur to somebody that it might not be a good idea to mock an entire continent before the world's largest athletic competition that, by the way, happens to take place on that continent. Were they not aware of an invention called "the Internet" that allows pictures taken in Spain to be transmitted all over the world for the eyes of everyone?

And now that the inevitable controversy has hit, they're still defending themselves when a simple, "the ad was in poor taste, we apologize" would have sufficed. This story would be slowing down if the Spanish Basketball team had apologized immediately. Now it's just picking up steam.

The Organization of Chinese-Americans has released multiple statements condemning the picture. George Wu, deputy director of the group, said, "it is unfortunate that this type of imagery would rear its head during something that is supposed to be a time of world unity." Response in Beijing has been muted so far.

Madrid is thought to be one of the frontrunners to land the 2016 Summer Games (the site will be announced next year). Could this controversy hurt Spain's chances of landing another Olympics?

Interestingly, the Spanish basketball team took on China tonight, winning 85-75 in overtime. No word on whether Pau Gasol was on the receiving end of any elbows from Yao Ming. The Chinese crowd did have a message for the Spainards though, booing vigorously during the game.
The Chinese have been excellent hosts and very hospitable so far, even politely cheering the Japanese delegation. Booing is very rare. For them to boo the Spanish team speaks volumes.

Here's the offending photo:

xepherys 08-12-2008 06:11 PM

Well, lots of people, Americans included, seem to like to believe that Europeans are much more "civilized" than Americans. Frankly, it's just not true. Americans are just more boisterous about our obnoxious habits and ways of being. There are just as many asshats in European countries (and at least triple the number, per capita, in France) :p

Willravel 08-12-2008 06:17 PM

It was kinda dumb, but I don't have direct evidence there was ill intent. As such, I can only fault them for ignorance to racially inappropriate behavior.

Jetée 08-12-2008 06:19 PM

The photo seems more like they are trying to concentrate on blowing up my mind, a la Charles Xavier, though that may be more to do with the resolution of it.

I tend not to be too involved with the underlying aspects of what some do to entertain themselves. Sure, they offended an entire nation of people off-handedly, but worse things could happen other than making yourselves out to be international douchenozzles by not thinking why this discriminatory gesture might've ticked some off.

Bad move, obviously, to insult the hand that "hosts", but at least they might learn to teach their athletes and population in general to be more aware of other cultures, and to act with dignity in order to be viewed as respectable competitors, instead of world-class jerks.

jorgelito 08-12-2008 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xepherys (Post 2505957)
Well, lots of people, Americans included, seem to like to believe that Europeans are much more "civilized" than Americans. Frankly, it's just not true. Americans are just more boisterous about our obnoxious habits and ways of being. There are just as many asshats in European countries (and at least triple the number, per capita, in France) :p

Sarcasm. I know man, I just felt like taking a swing at the Europeans cause we Americans always get so much shit for this type of thing. :p
-----Added 12/8/2008 at 10 : 43 : 32-----
Quote:

Originally Posted by Willravel (Post 2505963)
It was kinda dumb, but I don't have direct evidence there was ill intent. As such, I can only fault them for ignorance to racially inappropriate behavior.

I agree with you, I don't think there was ill intent either. That's the nature of ignorance and institutionalized/indoctrinated racism/prejudice. Regardless, it was still abhorrent for them to do that. And yes, it was definitely dumb.

Another way to think about it is substitution: If they had mocked blacks by making monkey faces or Jews by making their noses big etc etc, no one would find this funny or tolerate it. Nor would they be making excuses for them either.

Just food for thought.

Willravel 08-12-2008 06:48 PM

Oh, I don't think it's funny. Think of it this way: let's say you have a 4 year old who's never seen a black person before and gets freaked out when they see one. Am I comparing the social ability of these basketball players to 4 year olds? Yes.

*Nikki* 08-12-2008 06:50 PM

It's a FACT that Asians eyes are not round. Am I the only one who is not bothered by this photo or who doesn't think it is offensive??

xepherys 08-12-2008 06:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Nikki* (Post 2505997)
It's a FACT that Asians eyes are not round. Am I the only one who is not bothered by this photo or who doesn't think it is offensive??

*I* could personally care less, but it's not on me what others find offensive. This is, I think, pretty well known to be a played out offense against Asian folk. *shrug*

jorgelito 08-12-2008 06:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Nikki* (Post 2505997)
It's a FACT that Asians eyes are not round. Am I the only one who is not bothered by this photo or who doesn't think it is offensive??

Because you are not Asian I am guessing. The offense has very little to do with the actual eye shape of Asians and everything to do with the action. This behaviour/gesture is commonly used to mock, insult, and denigrate Asians in a very real way that often leads to violence. Of course you won't find it offensive because there is no context for you.

The fact that you don't know or realize this is indicative that we have long, long way to go.

thingstodo 08-13-2008 02:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jorgelito (Post 2506004)

The fact that you don't know or realize this is indicative that we have long, long way to go.

It doesn't mean much to me either way. If the Chinese get upset, that is their right, just as it is the team's right to take the photo. And I guess they bood to show their displeasure.

What I do think is that we worry too much about this sort of thing. It won't change my life one way or the other.

So Nikki...you aren't the only one!!

pig 08-13-2008 03:17 AM

I don't know - if the next Olympics are held in South Africa, and the Chinese team dressed up in blackface for a commercial, how would y'all feel about it? I doubt very seriously that the team intended to offend anyone. I can see how the Chinese would be offended, however.

Halx 08-13-2008 04:09 AM

Are there any asians in here who are offended or is it just we unaffected folk who are taking up the flag?

little_tippler 08-13-2008 04:18 AM

I think a lot of people are being very anal about this. I don't think it was done with the intent to be offensive. I think the fact that people pick up on it as offensive also speaks volumes about the long way they still have to go to stop jumping on each other because of "racism". We are different, that is a fact. Or are we going to pretend we all look the same? I think the Spanish were probably just happy about the China Olympics and made this playful gesture, not to offend, but to acknowledge. I honestly wouldn't read more into it...obviously this was over-analyzed later and here we are.

I do understand that the gesture may have been used to offend previously. Maybe they didn't stop to think about the centuries of history relating to that and how it could be construed. I do think they were foolish to think the Chinese would take it lightly. The Chinese take everything very seriously, because they are very defensive that way, about their heritage and culture. They definitely have an us against them attitude. So it was silly of the Spanish to do this...but I don't think they were racist.

I also find it inappropriate that several of the people who have responded to this thread have taken the opportunity to take jibes at Europeans, while condemning the Spanish attitude. I have no prejudice against Americans or any other nationality, or "race". Obviously you have a chip on your shoulder and that's a shame.

If more people stopped thinking of "racism" all the time maybe then we could actually all get along. I also think that *Nikki* has a point and was brave enough to speak her mind, in an unprejudiced, uncensored way. Everything is so ultra-PC these days it makes me gag.

Poppinjay 08-13-2008 04:27 AM

They should never have mocked asians by pantomiming slanty eyes. The should have demonstrated poor driving skills instead.

Leto 08-13-2008 05:42 AM

I think it was in bad taste. But I don't get what the pre-occupation is with oriental eyes. So there's a fold of skin. Big deal, why do non-oriental people need to pick on that detail? The eyballs are just as spherical as anybody's.

I have a friend, a girl from Holland, who tries to compete with my wife (an oriental of Han descent) on the 'slantedness' of her eyes. She claims that because she is Dutch, she has slanted eyes. She claims that being Dutch gives her this attribute honestly, while my wife's eyes just 'appear' to be slanted because of the epicanthic fold.

My wife is just like, meh. whatever. She just objects to people using the gesture in a hurtful manner.

highthief 08-13-2008 07:28 AM

OK, it's obviously offensive - the people at the China-Spain game didn't like it, various Asians have commented on it in a negative fashion. Not sure what the debate is?

Spain is a little silly sometimes with race relations. They had problems last year with Lewis Hamilton (the half black British F1 driver) and racism. Spain has had more than a few issues with soccer and racist chants. They are not the worst offenders by any means (Eastern Europe is far, far worse) but their sports teams and fans aren't always the brightest bulbs when it comes to this sort of thing.

ironpham 08-13-2008 07:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Halx (Post 2506130)
Are there any asians in here who are offended or is it just we unaffected folk who are taking up the flag?

I used to get offended by this. But, now I just push my "slanty eyes" inward to make them look round and say "Hey, look! I'm a whitey."

Quote:

They should never have mocked asians by pantomiming slanty eyes. The should have demonstrated poor driving skills instead.
I do get offended by shit like this though. No tickets/accidents after several years of driving, and I still have to hear this bullshit.

Jinn 08-13-2008 07:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Nikki* (Post 2505997)
It's a FACT that Asians eyes are not round. Am I the only one who is not bothered by this photo or who doesn't think it is offensive??

That's true, but no one's eyes are around. Two-dimensional vs. three-dimensional concerns aside (round is 2D, spherical is 3D), most people's eyes are more egg shaped than spherical.

And yea, I'm not really offended but I don't have slanty eyes. I don't know enough Asians to know if it's offensive, either.

Cynthetiq 08-13-2008 07:56 AM

I'm not offended by the photo. I'm offended by all the hullabaloo this has generated.

How would this gesture offend me? Well if they walked up to me and did the gesture and said, "Hey Chink!" I'd take some mild offense to the idea that they were trying to get a rise out of me. Otherwise, why is this a real concern?

I'm with tippler, if we acknowledge differences we have as human beings and stop carrying on the race/religion aspects, we'd be much better off. It seems to me that we're being force fed the idea we have to have some sort of instant offended button when it comes to race/religion. It's absurd.

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 08:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Nikki* (Post 2505997)
It's a FACT that Asians eyes are not round. Am I the only one who is not bothered by this photo or who doesn't think it is offensive??

Nope. Ditto. Once again, people LOVE to overreact. :shakehead:

Willravel 08-13-2008 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoganSnake (Post 2506245)
Nope. Ditto. Once again, people LOVE to overreact. :shakehead:

http://www.easylittlesaigon.com/imag...e_lg_asian.jpg

Reese 08-13-2008 08:12 AM

Well I'd be mad! they did it wrong! Chinese you're supposed to pull your eye out and down a little! duh every 8 year old knows that!

no.. seriously.. Kinda immature for Olympians. I had to teach my little sisters a few days ago not to do that chinese/japanese thing because it was offensive and untrue

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 08:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Willravel (Post 2506250)



Exactly. This is about as offensive to me as an Arab team taping payot to their sideburns before a game in Israel. And I'm a Jew.

In fact, I'd probably LOL.

*waits for people to tell me how it's unfair to compare physical characteristics with religious ones*

Leto 08-13-2008 08:19 AM

nope... just wondering what payot is. Don't some First Peoples smoke that in religious ceremonies?

djtestudo 08-13-2008 08:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ironpham (Post 2506236)
I used to get offended by this. But, now I just push my "slanty eyes" inward to make them look round and say "Hey, look! I'm a whitey."

There's an Asian comedian that does this joke, and I was trying to find a picture of it.

Willravel 08-13-2008 08:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoganSnake (Post 2506255)
Exactly. This is about as offensive to me as an Arab team taping payot to their sideburns before a game in Israel. And I'm a Jew.

In fact, I'd probably LOL.

*waits for people to tell me how it's unfair to compare physical characteristics with religious ones*

Actually that'd be a bit worse. It's not like there is a holy war between China and Spain.

Spain: holy war free for *196,735* days.

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 08:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leto (Post 2506259)
nope... just wondering what payot is. Don't some First Peoples smoke that in religious ceremonies?

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...oung_hasid.jpg

Those long sideburns are payot.

You're thinking of peyote.

jorgelito 08-13-2008 09:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pig (Post 2506115)
I don't know - if the next Olympics are held in South Africa, and the Chinese team dressed up in blackface for a commercial, how would y'all feel about it? I doubt very seriously that the team intended to offend anyone. I can see how the Chinese would be offended, however.

Yes, I don't think the Spanish intentionally intended to offend or be racist but nonetheless, their behavior was highly offensive and unacceptable. They've done similar things in the past where they made monkey noises at a visiting African team. However, they were puished for that one. Really, this is indefensible.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Halx (Post 2506130)
Are there any asians in here who are offended or is it just we unaffected folk who are taking up the flag?

Yes. Why? Does it matter? I'm not black but I am offended at racist jibes at black folk too.

Quote:

Originally Posted by little_tippler (Post 2506134)
I think a lot of people are being very anal about this. I don't think it was done with the intent to be offensive. I think the fact that people pick up on it as offensive also speaks volumes about the long way they still have to go to stop jumping on each other because of "racism". We are different, that is a fact. Or are we going to pretend we all look the same? I think the Spanish were probably just happy about the China Olympics and made this playful gesture, not to offend, but to acknowledge. I honestly wouldn't read more into it...obviously this was over-analyzed later and here we are.

I do understand that the gesture may have been used to offend previously. Maybe they didn't stop to think about the centuries of history relating to that and how it could be construed. I do think they were foolish to think the Chinese would take it lightly. The Chinese take everything very seriously, because they are very defensive that way, about their heritage and culture. They definitely have an us against them attitude. So it was silly of the Spanish to do this...but I don't think they were racist.

I also find it inappropriate that several of the people who have responded to this thread have taken the opportunity to take jibes at Europeans, while condemning the Spanish attitude. I have no prejudice against Americans or any other nationality, or "race". Obviously you have a chip on your shoulder and that's a shame.

If more people stopped thinking of "racism" all the time maybe then we could actually all get along. I also think that *Nikki* has a point and was brave enough to speak her mind, in an unprejudiced, uncensored way. Everything is so ultra-PC these days it makes me gag.

Wow, so funny that you don't find the Chinky eyes to be offensive but find the European comments to be offensive. What does this have to do with PC? Why does it make you gag? It makes me sad to see how you fail to see another segment of our population's humanity.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Poppinjay (Post 2506140)
They should never have mocked asians by pantomiming slanty eyes. The should have demonstrated poor driving skills instead.

This is extremely offensive and inappropriate.

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoganSnake (Post 2506245)
Nope. Ditto. Once again, people LOVE to overreact. :shakehead:

False. How is it overreacting? I don't I'm overreacting at all.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Willravel (Post 2506266)
Actually that'd be a bit worse. It's not like there is a holy war between China and Spain.

Spain: holy war free for *196,735* days.

Please don't belittle the issue here.

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 09:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jorgelito (Post 2506292)
False. How is it overreacting? I don't I'm overreacting at all.

Do tell why this is offensive to you if you are not of Asian descent.

And overreacting because of this:

Quote:

....a move that could offend its Olympic hosts in Beijing
Have the hosts commented on it?

Besides, why would somebody from People's Republic of KKKalifornia find anything offensive?

Poppinjay 08-13-2008 09:41 AM

Quote:

This is extremely offensive and inappropriate.
That's why I wrote it. But I have to give credit, the idea for the line came from a "Drawn Together" episode.

What the Spanish team did wasn't funny because they're dumb jocks.

When you offend, you have to do it with flava.

Willravel 08-13-2008 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jorgelito (Post 2506292)
Please don't belittle the issue here.

Believe it or not, I wasn't. If an Arab team was taping payot to their sideburns before a game in Israel, it would be decidedly worse than Spanish basketball players slanting their eyes.

I keep asking Asian or pac-islander friends about this, and not one of them has cared even a little. Many thought it was funny. I love defending people when I feel they're being mistreated, but I'm having trouble really getting worked up about this one because I feel like I'd be defending political correctness and not actual people.

ironpham 08-13-2008 09:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Poppinjay (Post 2506303)
That's why I wrote it. But I have to give credit, the idea for the line came from a "Drawn Together" episode.

What the Spanish team did wasn't funny because they're dumb jocks.

When you offend, you have to do it with flava.

So you wrote it to offend any onlooking Asians? The Spanish team probably weren't trying to offend anyone with that picture. You, however, are starting to cross the line.

Quote:

I keep asking Asian or pac-islander friends about this, and not one of them has cared even a little. Many thought it was funny. I love defending people when I feel they're being mistreated, but I'm having trouble really getting worked up about this one because I feel like I'd be defending political correctness and not actual people.
As I said previously, I'm not offended by what they did. I think the Chinese (who were booing the Spain basketball team during their match against China) tend to be a little more uptight about these matters. The difference might be that they live in China, and they probably don't see anyone doing that. Your friends are most likely living around areas with less Asians and more Europeans/Americans/non-Asians, so they have seen things like this before.

jorgelito 08-13-2008 09:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoganSnake (Post 2506298)
Do tell why this is offensive to you if you are not of Asian descent.

And overreacting because of this:



Have the hosts commented on it?

Besides, why would somebody from People's Republic of KKKalifornia find anything offensive?

Sure. It's offensive to me on two levels: One, as an Asian, the Chinky eyes was one of many tools used to put me down not only verbally but as the precursor for extreme violence. It was often the last thing I saw before being pummeled by others. It was usually accompanied by the "ching chong ching chong" taunt so loved by racist bullies everywhere. Additionally I do not see it as overreacting. I don't know what the Chinese (government) but I do know that they do not want anything to disrupt their Olympics and will sweep this under the rug. They will evaluate the situation critically and look at outcomes and consequences. I started this thread as an expression of my objection to this type of behavior and to share with others that this is not cool.

Two: I don't see it as a PC thing but rather as a respect thing. Regardless of your race, ethnicity, religion, affiliation etc, we should all strive to be more understanding and respectful of each other. Therefore, this behavior is unacceptable and offensive to me on that level and as a human being.

I get your point though. I hope you see mine
-----Added 13/8/2008 at 01 : 57 : 55-----
Quote:

Originally Posted by Poppinjay (Post 2506303)
That's why I wrote it. But I have to give credit, the idea for the line came from a "Drawn Together" episode.

What the Spanish team did wasn't funny because they're dumb jocks.

When you offend, you have to do it with flava.

Haha, ok, touche friend. What is "Drawn Together"?

Don't be so harsh on the Spanish team though. Apparently not all of them were ok with it (including Pau Gasol) and were goaded into doing it by the photographer. Jose Calderon on the other hand...

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jorgelito (Post 2506312)
I get your point though. I hope you see mine

I see that this is tied with your negative personal experiences. Going by that, I can see why this would bother you.

What I don't understand is why it would bother non-Asians unless they were hardcore supporters of political correctness.

JohnBua 08-13-2008 10:01 AM

This photo is proof that the world needs a chill pill.

Poppinjay 08-13-2008 10:01 AM

Quote:

So you wrote it to offend any onlooking Asians? The Spanish team probably weren't trying to offend anyone with that picture. You, however, are starting to cross the line
.


What line and who drew it? You? Have you written letters of disgust to Margaret Cho for her mockery of Asian cultural ethos?

I grew up in the south, and I love things that mock southerners. I watch Squidbillies and think, "my God, they're in my hometown."

Congrats on your driving record. Mine solidly reflects the C I got in driver's ed.

Willravel 08-13-2008 10:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jorg
Sure. It's offensive to me on two levels: One, as an Asian, the Chinky eyes was one of many tools used to put me down not only verbally but as the precursor for extreme violence. It was often the last thing I saw before being pummeled by others. It was usually accompanied by the "ching chong ching chong" taunt so loved by racist bullies everywhere.

OH, YOU'RE ASIAN. Dude, I didn't know. Still, you're the first of my Asian friends to find it offensive. But that's totally your right.

Poppinjay 08-13-2008 10:07 AM

Quote:

Haha, ok, touche friend. What is "Drawn Together"?
It's a cartoon show on Comedy Central, very offensive to pretty much everybody. It has superheroes including a Superman type who has lapses of self-confidence, a Pickachu who is based on Asian stereotypes, a blaxsploitation heroinne "Foxy", Wooldoor Sockbat who I have no idea what he is, a gay elf hero, a virginal princess, a boozy, disgusting elderly betty boop type, and a pig who acts like... well... a pig.

http://www.comedycentral.com/shows/d...st/index.jhtml

jorgelito 08-13-2008 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Willravel (Post 2506320)
OH, YOU'RE ASIAN. Dude, I didn't know. Still, you're the first of my Asian friends to find it offensive. But that's totally your right.

Haha, the secret's out (you make it sound like a disease :LOL:). No but seriously, I don't go around looking to be offended, just sharing my experience and trying to evolve. You have to look at context too. I grew up as the only Asian kid in my school until about grade 7. Racism was not uncommon. However, most of my Asian friends that grew up in major Asian areas like LA and the Bay area did not experience these types of things or at least not as often. It makes a difference.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Poppinjay (Post 2506321)
It's a cartoon show on Comedy Central, very offensive to pretty much everybody. It has superheroes including a Superman type who has lapses of self-confidence, a Pickachu who is based on Asian stereotypes, a blaxsploitation heroinne "Foxy", Wooldoor Sockbat who I have no idea what he is, a gay elf hero, a virginal princess, a boozy, disgusting elderly betty boop type, and a pig who acts like... well... a pig.

Meet the Cast | Drawn Together  | Comedy Central

Cool man, thanks for the link. I love this type of stuff (satire). For clarification, I tend to view satire differently than say for example the photo and such.

abaya 08-13-2008 10:22 AM

Well, this might make me a hypocrite, but I'm all for making fun of your own people group... just not anyone else's. Luckily, I'm half-white (European, even!) and half-Asian, so I can get away with a lot. :p

What this team did is just plain disappointing and rude. I am not personally offended by it, but I don't think it's funny, nor is it something that should be joked about in any capacity; if other people find it offensive (whether they are Asian or not), who am I to take that right away from them? I find it disappointing when these kinds of things happen, and even more disappointing if they go by unnoticed (e.g. without anyone "overreacting" to them).
Quote:

Originally Posted by little_tippler
The Chinese take everything very seriously, because they are very defensive that way, about their heritage and culture. They definitely have an us against them attitude.

I'm afraid I have to disagree... because it's not just the Chinese who do this. Plenty of people groups take themselves quite seriously, to the point where you might say it's a universal human trait. I don't think it's fair to say that "all the Chinese are so defensive," when many groups (or even just individuals within those groups) would react in similar ways. Not that this is a very positive trait, but it's certainly understandable given the context and history.

But, in case it's not clear by now, I am the type of person who is quite fine with being PC, and I am much more comfortable erring on the side of being "ultra-PC" than with the possibility of offending others. As was discussed in another thread, I see it as being an issue of manners and respect. You can't go wrong by showing too much respect--if someone unearns the respect you've given them, then that's their mistake.

ironpham 08-13-2008 10:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Poppinjay (Post 2506319)
.


What line and who drew it? You? Have you written letters of disgust to Margaret Cho for her mockery of Asian cultural ethos?

I grew up in the south, and I love things that mock southerners. I watch Squidbillies and think, "my God, they're in my hometown."

Congrats on your driving record. Mine solidly reflects the C I got in driver's ed.

Sure, I drew it. What does it matter to you? You offended me by calling me and the rest of the Asians of the world bad drivers. What happened to the rest of the drivers in the world? Does no one else get in car accidents? Does no one else drive like an idiot? Why does a bad driver automatically constitute that the person is Asian (or a woman I guess)?

Congratulations on being able to "mock southerners". I can mock my own people too, but I try not to mock other cultures because much like jorgelito, I've been on the ass end of it and I know how it feels. There's a difference between insulting your own culture and insulting others.

Willravel 08-13-2008 10:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jorgelito (Post 2506327)
Haha, the secret's out (you make it sound like a disease :LOL:). No but seriously, I don't go around looking to be offended, just sharing my experience and trying to evolve. You have to look at context too. I grew up as the only Asian kid in my school until about grade 7. Racism was not uncommon. However, most of my Asian friends that grew up in major Asian areas like LA and the Bay area did not experience these types of things or at least not as often. It makes a difference.

You must have grown up in one of the inland valleys. I lived near Stockton for a bit and it was a lot different than San Jose. It also explains why you're a conservative. California is liberal by the majority, but there are defiantly conservative areas. When the revolution comes, those will be the battlegrounds....:expressionless:

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 10:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ironpham (Post 2506337)
Congratulations on being able to "mock southerners". I can mock my own people too, but I try not to mock other cultures because much like jorgelito, I've been on the ass end of it and I know how it feels. There's a difference between insulting your own culture and insulting others.

I've also been on the ass end of it, so? Yeah, it sucks, but you move on. Doesn't stop me from mocking other cultures.

Not to hurt the person, mind you, but in jest.

And a little off topic, yes, there are plenty of idiot drivers out there. However, 70% of them in MY case are women.

KellyC 08-13-2008 11:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Halx (Post 2506130)
Are there any asians in here who are offended or is it just we unaffected folk who are taking up the flag?

Nope. I can't for the life of me find anything offensive about the picture. Although this is not the first time the Asian community has overreacted over trivial things people do. I agree with whoever said people tend to overreact.


I am offended that they are offended.

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KellyC (Post 2506353)
I agree with whoever said people tend to overreact.

It was LoganSnake.

ironpham 08-13-2008 11:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoganSnake (Post 2506349)
I've also been on the ass end of it, so? Yeah, it sucks, but you move on. Doesn't stop me from mocking other cultures.

Not to hurt the person, mind you, but in jest.

And a little off topic, yes, there are plenty of idiot drivers out there. However, 70% of them in MY case are women.

I know most of the time mocking to harm is not intentional (spelling?). I'm sure poppinjay didn't mean to harm either. But, sometimes it does (a good example is the Spain photo to China) and sometimes people do mean offense. That's why I try not to.

Yeah, I did make a big fuss out of this. That's my point. You might not mean to make offense, but that doesn't matter. Some people will take offense.

And, actually, I'm glad I've gone through what I have. Much like jorgelito, I got beat up and mocked all the time in middle/high school. The positive is it taught me how to fight. Now people don't fuck with me because they've seen what I've done to people that have.

jorgelito 08-13-2008 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by abaya (Post 2506329)
Well, this might make me a hypocrite, but I'm all for making fun of your own people group... just not anyone else's. Luckily, I'm half-white (European, even!) and half-Asian, so I can get away with a lot. :p

What this team did is just plain disappointing and rude. I am not personally offended by it, but I don't think it's funny, nor is it something that should be joked about in any capacity; if other people find it offensive (whether they are Asian or not), who am I to take that right away from them? I find it disappointing when these kinds of things happen, and even more disappointing if they go by unnoticed (e.g. without anyone "overreacting" to them). I'm afraid I have to disagree... because it's not just the Chinese who do this. Plenty of people groups take themselves quite seriously, to the point where you might say it's a universal human trait. I don't think it's fair to say that "all the Chinese are so defensive," when many groups (or even just individuals within those groups) would react in similar ways. Not that this is a very positive trait, but it's certainly understandable given the context and history.

But, in case it's not clear by now, I am the type of person who is quite fine with being PC, and I am much more comfortable erring on the side of being "ultra-PC" than with the possibility of offending others. As was discussed in another thread, I see it as being an issue of manners and respect. You can't go wrong by showing too much respect--if someone unearns the respect you've given them, then that's their mistake.

Wow, very nicely written Abaya. I really have nothing to say except that I wish I had written this. Thank you for your thoughtful contribution.
-----Added 13/8/2008 at 03 : 34 : 41-----
Quote:

Originally Posted by Willravel (Post 2506340)
You must have grown up in one of the inland valleys. I lived near Stockton for a bit and it was a lot different than San Jose. It also explains why you're a conservative. California is liberal by the majority, but there are defiantly conservative areas.

Actually I grew up in Boston (go figure).
Quote:

When the revolution comes, those will be the battlegrounds....:expressionless:
Doh! You went there! :eek:
-----Added 13/8/2008 at 03 : 38 : 20-----
Quote:

Originally Posted by LoganSnake (Post 2506349)
I've also been on the ass end of it, so? Yeah, it sucks, but you move on. Doesn't stop me from mocking other cultures.

Not to hurt the person, mind you, but in jest.

It's good to know that you are not intending to hurt anyone but just bear in mind this type of behavior often does. Not you perhaps, but this is very real and used to purposefully hurt others in a very real way. Yes, we move on, for sure I agree, and part of that moving on is expressing our displeasure and objection to things like this. Nothing wrong with that right?

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoganSnake (Post 2506349)
And a little off topic, yes, there are plenty of idiot drivers out there. However, 70% of them in MY case are women.

:eek: :expressionless:

LoganSnake 08-13-2008 12:02 PM

Yeah, I went there.

Willravel 08-13-2008 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jorgelito (Post 2506378)
Actually I grew up in Boston (go figure).

Beaner.

Vigilante 08-13-2008 12:37 PM

Ah, such a serious world we live in.

I'm gonna go against the grain here. I find it hilarious.

If the chinese team had a sense of humor, they would have made a picture of the team dancing around sombreros wearing flamenco shoes, or even darkened their own skin and pulled their own eyes into an exaggerated downward slanted look with a scoreboard behind them showing the chinese winning the game. Is this juvenile? Yes, absolutely. However if you show anger when someone pokes at you, you lose. Laugh and poke back, and everyone gets the joke. The chinese gov't has the collective sense of humor of a hornet's nest though (and I wonder of about some people here, come on folks) so this reaction of outrage is not surprising.

To me, this is why we don't get along, folks. It's not the ignorance, it's the reactions.
-----Added 13/8/2008 at 04 : 38 : 28-----
Quote:

Originally Posted by Willravel (Post 2506408)
Beaner.

:lol:

That's my wife's nickname.

Psycho Dad 08-13-2008 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cynthetiq (Post 2506242)
It seems to me that we're being force fed the idea we have to have some sort of instant offended button when it comes to race/religion. It's absurd.

Sums it up. Couple this with the fact that the media likes to make these things bigger than they are we will all have something to talk about for a day or two. Then we can move on to the next world "crisis".

kutulu 08-13-2008 02:46 PM

What is wrong with people just being aware that this type of behavior is inappropriate and not acting that way?

jorgelito 08-13-2008 02:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kutulu (Post 2506475)
What is wrong with people just being aware that this type of behavior is inappropriate and not acting that way?

I wonder the same thing. It seems most people in here blame us for being offended rather than condemning the behaviour itself.

abaya 08-13-2008 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kutulu (Post 2506475)
What is wrong with people just being aware that this type of behavior is inappropriate and not acting that way?

Well, if you ask me (and actually, I just started a related thread about this)... one of the problems is that people don't want to feel guilty for being okay with this kind of behavior. So they make a joke out of it, or tell others to "lighten up," or condemn the person for being offended. I would say that it's a pretty strong component of human nature--I see it in myself all the time, when I feel guilty about something and get defensive, or start minimizing the other party's feelings--but that's getting pretty psychological here. I'll mention it in the other thread. :)

MSD 08-13-2008 03:39 PM

The way I see it, the less seriously we take our differences, the better we're doing. If we can joke about it and all laugh, we're doing it right.

Ayashe 08-13-2008 04:23 PM

It was an idiotic ad, though the ones truly responsible for it would have been whoever was running that photo shoot. I would have to say that the team was not the one being sold in the photo but the product. The manufacturers of the product have a lot more say in what is being represented in their advertisements then the team that was simply trying to cash in and pay expenses. I doubt it was their choice to pose in that manner. It doesn't make it more right.

Halx 08-13-2008 04:30 PM

All the Spanish players in the ad are confused about the controversy. Can't we all take a cue from them and be a little blissful about it?

Vigilante 08-13-2008 04:44 PM

As I said in a somewhat wordier fashion above, I agree. Learn to laugh at yourself, and laugh at juvenile humor. Quit suing for stupid crap, quit creating outrage over little school shit that can be laughed at, or better yet poke back in a similar fashion.

It's stupid, it's grade school humor, and it's FUNNY. I'm a honkey, he's got slanted eyes, the black guy has the biggest penis every time, and it usually backfires. Let's just laugh it off and have a beer, margarita, whatever.

Ayashe 08-13-2008 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Halx (Post 2506555)
All the Spanish players in the ad are confused about the controversy. Can't we all take a cue from them and be a little blissful about it?

You make a very good point, however I cannot really speak of how I would feel if I felt the joke were on me.

Vigilante 08-13-2008 04:47 PM

If they put on white powder, made their lips pinkish and started dancing very badly, what white person wouldn't laugh? A KKK member maybe. It's just funny, if you step back and acknowledge the silliness.

jorgelito 08-13-2008 04:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MSD (Post 2506525)
The way I see it, the less seriously we take our differences, the better we're doing. If we can joke about it and all laugh, we're doing it right.

I agree 100% and I love this attitude. However, it doesn't occur in a vacuum nor does it occur overnight. It takes some time and process to get over and resolve previous wrongs. When there is parity then we will see things like this as no big deal. Just talking about it makes a big difference.
-----Added 13/8/2008 at 09 : 00 : 23-----
Quote:

Originally Posted by luciferase75 (Post 2506566)
As I said in a somewhat wordier fashion above, I agree. Learn to laugh at yourself, and laugh at juvenile humor. Quit suing for stupid crap, quit creating outrage over little school shit that can be laughed at, or better yet poke back in a similar fashion.

It's stupid, it's grade school humor, and it's FUNNY. I'm a honkey, he's got slanted eyes, the black guy has the biggest penis every time, and it usually backfires. Let's just laugh it off and have a beer, margarita, whatever.

Sure, but we're not quite there yet. It's a process. But we can still have our beer and margaritas eh?

Bear Cub 08-13-2008 05:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by luciferase75 (Post 2506570)
If they put on white powder, made their lips pinkish and started dancing very badly, what white person wouldn't laugh? A KKK member maybe. It's just funny, if you step back and acknowledge the silliness.

Sure, it would be funny to us, but its an apples to oranges comparison given that the Chinese culture is far less free spirited than our own.

Would you walk into a business meeting with a Chinese corporate executive with your fingers pulling at your eyes? Would you sit down in a Chinese restaurant and make slanty eyes when you order?

No. Well, maybe if you were a huge prick.

There's a time and a place for everything, and even assholes like myself will acknowledge this. The prestige and location of the Olympics makes it neither the time nor the place for even "light hearted" racism.

As far as the Spanish players in the ad being "confused" about the controversy, that's a cover your ass position to take if I've ever seen one. A 4th grader could have come up with a better excuse.

Vigilante 08-13-2008 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jorgelito (Post 2506575)
But we can still have our beer and margaritas eh?

Absolutely. Have blender, on mission. :D

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bear Cub (Post 2506577)
Sure, it would be funny to us, but its an apples to oranges comparison given that the Chinese culture is far less free spirited than our own.

Would you walk into a business meeting with a Chinese corporate executive with your fingers pulling at your eyes? Would you sit down in a Chinese restaurant and make slanty eyes when you order?

No. Well, maybe if you were a huge prick.

There's a time and a place for everything, and even assholes like myself will acknowledge this. The prestige and location of the Olympics makes it neither the time nor the place for even "light hearted" racism.

As far as the Spanish players in the ad being "confused" about the controversy, that's a cover your ass position to take if I've ever seen one. A 4th grader could have come up with a better excuse.

You make a point. However coddling is not necessarily the way to answer a crying baby. This is just me, ok? I like to poke people until they get irritated, and then see if they can start acting a bit immature themselves. This is how I've been for years, ever since I got out of that stupid 18yo piss-and-vinegar stage. Sure I might get slapped, kicked or punched, but I know it might happen and I roll with it. I might even poke a little right after the strike. It helps to loosen up the rigid ones. Some emotion is better than none.

So in my mind, this is just one little poke to get the quiet kid to come out of his shell a little.

Poppinjay 08-13-2008 05:38 PM

Quote:

Sure, I drew it. What does it matter to you? You offended me by calling me and the rest of the Asians of the world bad drivers. What happened to the rest of the drivers in the world? Does no one else get in car accidents? Does no one else drive like an idiot? Why does a bad driver automatically constitute that the person is Asian (or a woman I guess)?
Only old people, asians, Marylanders, young people, middle aged people, folks on their cell phones, people with hair, those guys, those other guys, anybody on the road, and YOU, yes YOU, drive poorly, according to where I am and what lane I want to be in.

In other words, hell is other people. Get it. Accept it.

You seem smart, I appreciate your dialogue. We're at loggerheads. But you're teaching me a new level of acceptance. Thank you.

willynilly 08-13-2008 06:39 PM



-+-{Important TFP Staff Message}-+-
racist and insensitive remarks have been removed.

ktspktsp 08-14-2008 12:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bear Cub (Post 2506577)
Would you walk into a business meeting with a Chinese corporate executive with your fingers pulling at your eyes? Would you sit down in a Chinese restaurant and make slanty eyes when you order?

No. Well, maybe if you were a huge prick.

There's a time and a place for everything, and even assholes like myself will acknowledge this. The prestige and location of the Olympics makes it neither the time nor the place for even "light hearted" racism.

Well said.

willynilly 08-14-2008 06:18 AM

Well apparently sarcasm is lost here. My point is that everyone has areas that they consider important to them. What the Spanish players did was offensive. Is it a crime? No, being offensive is not a crime, it is just low-class. It was not light-hearted humor. What if Chinese team all came out wearing afros during their games with the US or African nations?

LoganSnake 08-14-2008 07:04 AM

I would laugh my ass off.

Many people would probably overreact and a member of the black community would make a thread.

willynilly 08-14-2008 07:17 AM

Yeah, when I was a kid I probably would have laughed as well. But now that I have grown and matured, I have no time for that.

Everybody has things that they consider important to them. For example, many mentally handicapped support groups are offended by the movie Tropic Thunder because of the repeated use of the word retard. I am sure that there are people on this board who have retards for relatives. My brother-in-law's sister has downs syndrome, and then she was hit by a truck as a child. She has lived in a group home her adult life. She cannot help the way she was made. However, this is an R-rated movie, so the situation is a little different. You have to expect that you may find something offensive in a movie. The basketball team is appearing in an ad for a Spanish company, and no one has pointed that out.

At any rate, logansnake, I am sure that you have your sacred cows, Maybe a little respect for other's viewpoints will be inyour future.

dlish 08-14-2008 07:26 AM

i'd probably make the thread... but im not a member of the black community.

i find the photo an offence being a non asian (although technically speaking lebanon is part of asia) that someone would be so insensitive and silly enough to not have common courtesy for your hosts, irrespective of your view on them.

maybe its because i have seen my friends, family, vilified and in some instances attacked because they happen to be arab or muslim. i've been called names, she-lish has been heckled in the street and on public transport and forced to get off the train for going about her business.

the only people who cannot see the racism in the teams actions probably havent been vilified against.

its a sad day for the world when we refuse see that all we ask for is a little respect

LoganSnake 08-14-2008 07:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by willynilly (Post 2506934)
Yeah, when I was a kid I probably would have laughed as well. But now that I have grown and matured, I have no time for that.

At any rate, LoganSnake, I am sure that you have your sacred cows, Maybe a little respect for other's viewpoints will be in your future.

Ooooh, that hurt!

In any case, I have things that I would find offensive if they were being made fun of, sure. Physical disabilities, deformities and mutations. What the Spanish team did was funny. I see your point, really I do. But don't bellitle me for my opinion.

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlish (Post 2506942)
The only people who cannot see the racism in the teams actions probably haven't been vilified against.

I wear the Star of David around my neck (as an accessory, not as a religious symbol). Let's just say I wouldn't even think of doing that in Ukraine for the fear of my physical well being. Let's leave it at that.

Slims 08-14-2008 02:22 PM

Do you remember the Fighting Whities? That was no less 'offensive' than this picture. Why weren't we offended? Because it was a joke and so is this.

If Tiger Woods had shown up to a major golf tournament made up to look like the stereotypical grumpy, old, white golf pro, I would have doubled over laughing.

When SNL has an asian skit, it's funny. When Dave Chappelle makes fun of either black stereotypes or white ones, it's funny.

People need to lighten up.

pig 08-14-2008 02:41 PM

I do remember the Fightin Whities. The humor there, in my opinion, was the social satire of the use of Native American symbolism/cultural icons as school mascots. It was a tongue-in-cheek humor, which I thought was clever. I don't really see a socially-redeeming value to this image. How does it point out stereotypes or make any cultural statements? I do see that they were probably only making what was intended to be light-hearted joke - to be taken in the sense that Nikki alluded to earlier. However, I think it's a bit disingenuous to say that you can't see how people - Asian or otherwise - would be offended at it. I'm not about to take to the streets to protest it by any means; however, I think it probably wasn't the best idea. I think if you took the same concept and put an Asian team in the picture with them with little wigs cut out and pasted to their backs, you might have something that was more appropriate. If they showed some mutual skewering of national/ethnic stereotypes, then it might be a different story. However, this image to me, based on the little that I know about it, doesn't seem to make any statement making the racial stereotype seem absurd...but if anything, seems to playfully perpetuate the symbolism of the gesture.

All in all, I think it was a bad idea.
\

lotsofmagnets 08-14-2008 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by abaya (Post 2506329)
...(lots of words)... What this team did is just plain disappointing and rude. I am not personally offended by it...(several more words)...

+1. it just wasn´t a good idea.

Supple Cow 08-14-2008 06:00 PM

Hey guys, remember the episode of Firefly where Inara goes to the ball with that rich dandy, and then Mal and Kaylee end up there too because they're trying to score a job, and then things get a little heated between Mal and the dandy, some insults are dropped about money changing hands and then BOOM! Mal decides to deck the guy? Remember how later, in a private moment with Mal, Inara sums up the very same conundrum we are all faced with here? "You'll lay a man out for implying I'm a whore, yet you keep calling me one to my face."

What was Mal's response? "I might not show respect to your job, but he didn't respect you. That's the difference."



...So what I'm hearing a bunch of you saying is that it would have been a way better episode if Mal had been all, "Haha, yeah! She is a whore! Let's get drinks, man." What an awesome idea! Nobody gets hurt (well, except Inara but she's just a woman) and everybody gets to play happy and not discuss uncomfortable topics! Seriously, I think you guys are on to something - somebody go tell Joss Whedon, STAT. :rolleyes:

speshul-k 08-18-2008 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Willravel (Post 2505963)
It was kinda dumb, but I don't have direct evidence there was ill intent. As such, I can only fault them for ignorance to racially inappropriate behavior.

I agree with Will on this one. Seems like it was intended to be harmless but of course they should have known better or at least questioned the implications of this campaign!

evilbeefchan 08-22-2008 03:55 PM

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3141/...41c2a8.jpg?v=0

What were we talking about again?

Ayashe 08-22-2008 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by evilbeefchan (Post 2511579)

I guess someone had to do it. Had me laughing out of my seat.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2
© 2002-2012 Tilted Forum Project


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360