akito

Article

I found this funny. :P

hulk

It's great that they were actually found guilty in one lifetime, but 9mil is Gates' pissing against a wall

__________________
"'There's a tendency among the press to attribute the creation of a game to a single person,' says Warren Spector, creator of Thief and Deus Ex."
-- From an IGN game review.

catback

WTF, maybe they're not being clear enough but there's a patent on the method of data transfer from excel to access and it's not owned by MS and to top it off the guy can get the patent even though MS owns the software his patent utilizes? Maybe I'm just reading it wrong but there are too many BS patents as is. What next someone is gonna get a patent on the best way to open a door? It's sad modern day patents are the main reason why the world is lacking great inventors, with the cost of patents the average person can't afford to protect his invention and if they could they would probably infringe on some BS patent that some big corp threw out there just because they could.

I'd really like to see more of the details regarding this patent, I didn't think it was possible to patent intellectual property. Copyright yes but patent, haven't seen any patented software yet.

Glory's Sun

I didn't think you could patent common knowledge things?

bendsley

1)Which might be one of the reasons that Microsoft is backing proposals for a reform of the patent systems, according to this article [zdnet.com].

Microsoft is now getting one of those giants like IBM who will constantly be bugged by private patent owners (bogus or real) for money. My experience is that though large companies have many patents, the quality of their portfolio is relatively low as they like big numbers. Small companies, on the other hand, have either a completely worthless portfolio or a small but very powerfull portfolio. And a small production, so the backfire risk of a patent lawsuit towards Microsoft is negligible.

2)Basically, it went like this:

Microsoft obtains software product A.
Microsoft obtains software product B.
Microsoft begins making them work together.
Guy beats Microsoft to market.
Microsoft continues making their products work together.
Guy sues Microsoft, wins millions for being first to patent obvious method made "novel" by the fact that it works on those confusin' new computers.

This would work against Linux.

This crap would work on anything.

Microsoft did *NOTHING* wrong here. They didn't steal his stuff or anything. They just made their own products work together. It probably wouldn't even have been an issue if Excel and Access had been marketed under the same freaking product name.

DOWN WITH SOFTWARE PATENTS!

__________________
"You hear the one about the fella who died, went to the pearly gates? St. Peter let him in. Sees a guy in a suit making a closing argument. Says, "Who's that?" St. Peter says, "Oh, that's God. Thinks he's Denny Crane."

kutulu

Actually, I already have that patent. I got it this morning.


By the way, I figure you've opened at least 5 doors so far today. I'm reasonable so I'll only charge you $5. In the future, to avoid legal damages, I suggest you start crawling through windows. At least, until my patent on that goes through.

pacaveli

it's only 9 million so what the fuck does bill gates care lol

__________________
Check my blog out. Basically me talking about video games

http://gginsights.blogspot.com/

muckluck

I have a feeling that these anti-Microsoft (yet still use Windows XP...?), think Bill Gates is the Anti-christ type are going to have a rhapsodic riot over this... It is nice seeing the big time companies lose every once in awhile, but this shows how stupid software patents are. I think that we are going to get to the point were download status bars and the Maximize button are going to be patented, and all of those (mostly Linux) open source operating systems. whos creators are looking for no profit, are going to dissapear because they can't pay royalties. DOWN WITH SOFTWARE PATENTS!!

__________________

CityOfAngels

Sorry, I already got that one. I tried to patent squeezing through chimneys, but it turns out some old, fat guy in a red suit has that one already.

__________________
The words "love" and "life" go together. It is almost as if they are one. You must love to live, and you must live to love, or you have never lived nor loved at all.

SinisterMotives

So what did the guy have a patent on? CSV files?

vox_rox

In the first place, Microsoft only really fights thesoe things because they have an army of lawyers who, with sheer numbers, usually win against anyone. those who they really don't think they can win against they simply settle with. These settlements are./ eusually millions of dollars, which is about the same as their legal defense fund, so it all comes out in the wash.

This guy, unfrostunately for Microsoft, just spun the wheel and got lucky. So what does that mean in the real world? Nothing. Will your Windows operating system or Microsoft's monopoly on the desktop change? Absolutely not.

All it means to anyone is that MS lost a case, paid a pittanance to deal with it, and it's over.

I wish it was mor eground-breaking than that. I wish it was the beginning of the end of MS and their crap. It's not.

Sorry.

Still, download and install Linux before it's tooal late. Ubuntu rocks!

Peace,

Pierre

__________________
---
There is no such thing as strong coffee - only weak people.
---