I don't ever remember getting a really cool V-Day gift....the obligatory card and flowers, sure. But nothing ever......special.
Mind you I never got anything overly tacky so I shouldn't complain I suppose!
Ultimate V-Day gift would not have to include a big fancy gift or anything - just the realization that your love really tried to please you.....for me it would be something really crazy like a hot air balloon ride (although it's too damn cold where I like to do that), or a trip to the zoo or a bonfire somewhere.........actually - no that's not true. I've always had this crazy dream about celebrating Valentine's day somewhere tropical and warm...and having my sweetie lead me down after dark to a private beach where he's laid out candles and a little picnic. Then we could make love on the beach by moonlight and frolick naked in the waves.
Oh wait...too many details?