You can't compare them to say which is worse. Short term, alcohol is often worse- no one ever had one cigarette too many and got in a fight, had a one night stand they regret, tried to drive and killed other people.. but long term, sensible drinking in moderation is probably less likely to affect your health than smoking, and you won't damage other people through secondhand effects. Cloves don't just look like cigarettes, they ARE cigarettes and they have the same effect on your health, sometimes worse. Though djarum blacks do have a filter at least, which many cloves and flavoured cigarettes don't