Utilities look fine. I live in Oregon, that much for gas/elec each month seems about right.
Wash your own damn car by hand, you lazy bastards
.
Unforseen expenses does look too low, I concur with some of the other posters.
Why the high car insurance? It's a freakin' camaro. Up the premiums on that to around $1000. Use car insurance for the big items, not piddly little things like windshield replacement.
$1000 for gifts? WTF? If you're broke, your friends and family will understand. Buy them cheap shit, and make up for it when you have the cash.
Part time jobs aren't going to cut it, expecially when, combined, you're making around $17 bucks an hour. Assuming, after tax, of around $13.40/hour, the two of you need to work around 2200 hours a year, which is basically one full time job plus 200 hours of overtime. Combined.
Find a higher paying job(s), if possible. Or move in with another couple to help defer costs. Face it - in your current situation, you can't do it. You need more income, because the costs look about right to me.
Good luck.