1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. We've had very few donations over the year. I'm going to be short soon as some personal things are keeping me from putting up the money. If you have something small to contribute it's greatly appreciated. Please put your screen name as well so that I can give you credit. Click here: Donations
    Dismiss Notice

Slavery in America - is it really happening?

Discussion in 'General Discussions' started by chinese crested, Oct 27, 2011.

  1. Cayvmann

    Cayvmann Very Tilted

    ^^^ agreed. Most of the animal farmers I knew growing up treated their stock very well, up to the end. Some milk cows were treated as pets. Modern factory farms are horrible though.
     
  2. Baraka_Guru

    Baraka_Guru Möderätor Staff Member

    Location:
    Toronto
    This might be a topic for another thread, but about those animals you eat: where do you think they get their food from? If you eat a pig's worth of pork each year, you are also essentially consuming a pig's lifetime's worth of food (as cut short as it is---from a couple of months to a year, depending on the type). Vegetarianism is about minimizing suffering, not eliminating it (which is virtually impossible). That includes eating the "pig food" instead of the pig---at least the vegetarian portion of it (probably grain and/or corn and/or soybeans).
     
  3. Cayvmann

    Cayvmann Very Tilted

    Well, if we were actually built to be vegetarians... I know, another thread.

    The truth is, as a species, we would not have developed our larger brains, if we had not been eating an animal diet. High protein, and fat. Now, due mainly to processing, etc. we can get the nutrients from a vegetarian lifestyle. Even then we have to supplement vitamins, I'm thinking the B's and D, if I'm not mis-remembering. Highly processed foods, aren't they being touted as no no's, for some reason?

    Certain animals are very efficient, due to being natural vegetarians, at processing low quality foods, such as grains, soy, and corn, into more nutritionally dense foods, like meat, that we can easily digest, without lots, and lots of mechanical and chemical processing. Yes, an animal converts plant materials that we couldn't even eat, into tasty, nutritious meat, that we can. This is done throughout the animal kingdom, of which we are citizens. Let's not even get into what happens to the animals when we are directly competing for the food that they would have eaten. ( humans will win this battle, too. we're good at that. they will die, and probably die out altogether )

    I commend your trying to reduce suffering, I really do, but you might not be reducing overall suffering, but moving it to other venues, such as more field animals and insects. But they don't have the publicists that pigs have... jk
     
  4. Baraka_Guru

    Baraka_Guru Möderätor Staff Member

    Location:
    Toronto
    As a vegan, I eat far fewer food resources overall, which is part of the point. There is no equal "shifting" to other resources. Livestock requires plant resources to be produced as food. I'm just going straight to the plant resources, and eating far, far fewer of them than the animals I would have eaten.

    I'm not sure PETA's official stance (though they do have lots of great introductory information on these matters), but it is well known that humans are generalist omnivores, which means we can thrive on many, many different diets. Vegetarian/vegan diets happen to be some of them.

    So in terms of "competition for resources," I'm taxing far fewer food resources than the average North American by eschewing meat, eggs, and dairy.

    But that should be a no-brainer. The kind of thing PETA is raising with this campaign (or stunt, if you prefer) is a discussion of animal rights. As has already been brought up in this thread, the practice of factory farming is a huge problem. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that the average North American would be appalled to see what goes on in there in terms of pain and suffering even long before the animal is slaughtered at young age.

    It would be great if all meat, dairy, and egg production was done by sustainable and more humane farms. Treating animals with more dignity is something PETA wants to keep people thinking about.

    Don't get caught up in the controversy of PETA's; there is far more controversy going on in society regarding animal rights and it's happening wholesale and largely under the radar.
     
  5. Borla

    Borla Moderator Staff Member

    I think I respect animal life a great deal, I think probably more than most people. My pets live better, more comfortable lives, and have better health care, then most people in today's world do. My dog literally has his own freaking bedroom and a queen sized bed to sleep on. :eek: Before getting each of our pets we sat down and gave it a lot of consideration, including their care, the expense, and what their quality of life would be before getting them.

    That being said (and this may sound contradictory to some), I love eating meat, and I'm a hunter. However, I buy a side of beef each year from a friend/local farmer. His cattle are raised in an open pasture, well cared for, grass fed, hormone and anti-biotic free, and are almost raised as pets. We get our eggs from his son-in-law (one of my best friends) and daughter, who have free range chickens so they can teach their 4 year old the responsibility of caring for chores (he does much of the feeding and egg collecting himself, it is hilarious to see him showing his city-slicker little friends how to gently handle baby chics). Much of the cheese, chicken, pork, and other things we buy come from a couple of local farmer's markets where small time farmers from the area sell their wares. Though I find the quality far superior in food products like that, I also appreciate the fact that I know the vast majority of the animal products I consume are not coming from huge commercial farms where the quality of care for the animals is questionable at best. And between making those choices, and the way I care for my pets, I feel I'm putting my money where my mouth is so to speak in doing things that cost me more out of pocket to support the proper care of animals. As far as hunting goes, I absolutely will not shoot at an animal that I'm not sure I can hit with a single kill shot. In several years of hunting I have never once shot at an animal and either missed, or lost it after hitting it. On the other hand, I've passed up many shots that I think I would've hit, but I wasn't completely sure of at the time. I'm not out there to slaughter and kill, I'm out there to enjoy the outdoors and possibly bring some food home. I absolutely will not shoot at an animal that I don't personally plan on eating. The only exception that I would made (but haven't done yet) is possibly coyote hunting with my farmer friend because he has a problem with coyotes. They have killed chickens, turkeys, ducks, barn cats, and possibly even one of his small dogs that disappeared, so in reality aren't I helping protect them if I do that?

    My point is that there is a difference between respecting and placing value on life, even animal life, and being absurd. PETA is often absurd. You want killer whales to be afforded human rights? Really?!?! So are you going to charge them with murder when they kill and eat fish, seals, and other animals that by extension should get those same rights?!? The lack of logic is mind boggling, and the attention it draws is so negative as to overshadow any real good done by the group.

    If you choose not to hunt because you can't morally or emotionally do so, I respect that. If you choose not to eat meat for those reasons, or health reasons, or religious reasons, I respect that. Even if you choose to go full vegan for whatever reason, that's fine too (As long as you aren't like my wife's friend who says she is vegan but every other time we see her is eating 'just a little cheese on my salad' or says 'I just had to have a reuben sandwich'. Huh? Then you aren't vegan!!!/rant). But this whole thing just makes anyone who supports PETA look kind of loony in my mind.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  6. Of course its hamming it up like panto on the side of Peta, but having seen and heard whales in the wild (Bay of Biscay), where they have freedom to be whales with family, its sad that these poor captive performing animals will never know that freedom. Keeping them in a confined space reminds me too much of dogs in crates - some spend their lives with wire under their paws. I do strongly believe in whale sanctuarys, and that every dead whale washed up on shore should be delivered to the lying bastards at the nearest Japanese embassy so they have the corpses for 'scientific research' - added bonus, not having to run massive whalers would greatly lower greenhouse emissions. Everyone a winner. I do go to the circus - but if they have animals its because they are pets, and they do not perform for the public. I find them very entertaining - esp Circus Oz which I saw many many years ago.
     
  7. Cayvmann

    Cayvmann Very Tilted

    I think a point has been missed, or dismissed. We cannot directly eat a lot of the things that our food animals can. We cannot get the nutrients out of them that they can. The vegetation that we can easily assimilate, like nuts, fruit, and vegetables require a lot of land, and cultivation ( which by the way, however accidentally kills and mutilates native animals ). These foods are also very vulnerable to changes in climate, whereas grass is not. Modern processing can help us to eat stuff that we normally couldn't, that's nice, but can be problematic health wise. We will either have to eat the animals, or change the 'natural' plants to ones we can digest. This will displace food sources for the animals, whether we like it or not. This will cause those animals to become unnecessary, and a burden/competition to us, whether we like it or not. The world is covered in mostly grass. We can't eat grass, we would die of malnutrition if we tried. Yet, we can gain necessary nutrition from ruminants, which can eat grass. This is the circle of life. We should respect it. Evolution has given us this very efficient, yet fragile interconnected life.

    One way or another we are going to cause animals distress and harm. Minimizing suffering is a much more complex problem than a vegan diet can solve. To me, the vegan answer is a simple answer to make people feel better about themselves, than an actual solution to the problem to be addressed.

    By the way, some vegs in India use the cows as food processors by eating the fresh cow dung. Predigested grub, yum... Can't eat grass, but you can eat grass fed pooh.
     
  8. Baraka_Guru

    Baraka_Guru Möderätor Staff Member

    Location:
    Toronto
    Cayvmann, given the current setup of agriculture in the Western world, what you say is a poor excuse for eating meat—but we are going a bit off topic here.
     
  9. MJ Foghat

    MJ Foghat New Member

    I wonder if any of the flesh eating bacteria will form an organization to file a suit for better treatment of humans?
     
  10. Baraka_Guru

    Baraka_Guru Möderätor Staff Member

    Location:
    Toronto
    Then there are those who oppose abortion as murder. I suppose it's an issue of sentience. (Fetuses don't feel pain until around 20 weeks.)
     
  11. MJ Foghat

    MJ Foghat New Member

    Legally, a person doesn't exist until registered (a birth certificate is issued, or a person could qualify for one). But there are laws regarding the murder of a woman and her unborn child. I am intrigued by the idea of Texas executing a corporate "person".
    --- merged: Oct 28, 2011 4:12 PM ---
    I'm currently struggling with having the cat that has adopted us castrated. There are some valid reasons for, which I'm pretty sure he would argue against. I've had a vasectomy - would a cat vasectomy be a reasonable compromise?
     
  12. You can have the cats bolloxc removed and implants put in if appearance is the worry. If he has a vasectomy he will still want sex and so will be more likely to fight and fuck and contract feline aids, he would probably also want to scent mark his territory. If he is staying entire, you must be prepared to check his tackle like you do your own for lumps. Hope thats a help.
    Pigs are the most effective garbage disposal units. I do have a veggie chum who likes leather shoes. He buys 'death by natural causes' leather shoes.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  13. MJ Foghat

    MJ Foghat New Member

    I don't know about "checking his tackle" - he already likes me way to much.
     
  14. martian

    martian Server Monkey Staff Member

    Location:
    Mars
    Getting your cats fixed is one of those 'for their own good' things. It'll mean a few days of discomfort for him, but you'll both be happier in the long run. Do it.
     
  15. Cayvmann

    Cayvmann Very Tilted

    I am still coming to grips with how I feel about all this and gathering data, so I'll let this derail go. I do respect your conviction. Maybe I'll join you someday.
     
  16. issmmm

    issmmm Getting Tilted

    Shhhh!
    Next up PETA sues Raid for genicide of mosquitos
     
  17. cynthetiq

    cynthetiq Administrator Staff Member Donor

    Location:
    New York City
    You'll be sorry you didn't do it the first time he sprays on your clothing/shoes/bed/wall. Oh yeah, that's the kind of odor like the Seinfeld BO episode where the O left the B it's so bad.
     
  18. issmmm

    issmmm Getting Tilted

    I got no argument with you or anyone who is vegan, vegitarian, or otherwise. How/why you chose to live is entirely up to you. I assume that while some would hope that more of us were convertable to their way of thinking, PETA is a stone hanging from their neck.
    PETA first came to my attention way back when, when they would throw paint on people's fur coats. Even then it seemed a bit backwards to me. It occured to me then that if someone did that to me I would seek a means to be made whole, ie replacement cost. wouldn't that mean that the deaths of the 25 (arbitrary number cuz I don't know how many makes a coat) minks you wanted to prostest caused the death toll to double?
    Seems PETA's aim is for attention to a (given)legitiamte problem, but their method is a turn off.
     
  19. Taking the entire Tom out of the picture (if he has sprayed, use bio soap powder to wash walls down - anything amonia based and you are setting up a feline water sports session as he outmarks the invader), are you into like 'free Willy'. De they belong in Parks? Large fish in small bowl.
    We were going to start up tapeworm rescue one april first, see how many supporters we got. Forest pigs in India live on people poop. Hole on veranda, pigs roaming underneath - Q. Would you want to eat pork fed on your poop?
     
  20. cynthetiq

    cynthetiq Administrator Staff Member Donor

    Location:
    New York City
    Should any animals be in captivity? Those that have been domesticated cannot live in the wild. Even Willy didn't do so well and eventually died when he was released.