bingle

So in the depressed fog I was in Wednesday morning, I got to thinking about the possibility of a west-coast secession from the Union.

I think it would be really interesting to see the discussion provoked if a measure got on the ballot of a state to secede - I don't think it would ever pass, not yet anyway, but it would certainly strike some sparks.

For one thing, if, say, California were to attempt to secede, the rest of the US couldn't allow it. A civil war would be less costly to the US than losing California.

However, what if Maine, or some other small border state decided to secede? People wouldn't support a civil war, but neither would the government let the state go. Is there some sort of legal action the federal government could take? Would they just demand repayment of all federal money invested in the state, refuse to recognize the new nation, threaten embargoes, and things like that?

Personally, I think these questions are going to become more important - as has been posted elsewhere, we're deeply divided as a country and it's only getting worse. The evil political tricks practiced this last election is a sign everyone just wants to fight for power, not actually encourage democracy - things like redistricting, possibly rigged voting machines, shredding registrations, and posting threatening flyers. I don't see this healing - I think we're headed towards a split of some kind.

Bingle

cthulu23

We already fought a war over this. Regardless of the total lack of poitical will that supports this, the outcome would already be decided.

Whatever split there is at the moment, it has been more pronounced in the past. America will survive, for better or for worse.

Jeff

Why would they succeed? They'd want the support of the US. Besides, the people of ANY state as a majority wouldn't agree with succeeding from the US.

I don't like Bush much, but there's no way in hell, I'd go along with this idea. Sure, we're divided, but we're not THAT divided.

__________________
For those who believe in God, most of the big questions are answered. But for those of us who can't readily accept the God formula, the big answers don't remain stone-written. We adjust to new conditions and discoveries. We are pliable. Love need not be a command or faith a dictum. I am my own God. We are here to unlearn the teachings of the church, state, and our educational system. We are here to drink beer. We are here to kill war. We are here to laugh at the odds and live our lives so well that Death will tremble to take us.
--Charles Bukowski

meepa

I saw a funny map where it showed western Washington, western Oregon, Californa, and New England as annexed by Canada... Of course now I can't find it, but I'm sure you all have the imagination to see it in your minds and imagine it!

Halx

you mean this?

__________________
You have found this post informative.
-The Administrator
[Don't Feed The Animals]

SecretMethod70

Gimme a break....now you're all just being dramatic.

__________________
Le temps détruit tout

"Musicians are the carriers and communicators of spirit in the most immediate sense." - Kurt Elling

pan6467

I can see a time coming very soon where we may not have a choice BUT to break up the union as we know it today. As the deficit gets higher and foreign governments buy up our national and personal debts at a break neck pace eventually, those governments, such as China, will want to collect. The only way to get out of it and not become a foreign controlled colony would then be to disband. Whether it would be into a peaceful confederacy of smaller sovereign states that have centralized governments that band together to form a military or a warring factions of states each wanting their own country recognized.

Just to make sure people understand I do not mean "states" as they appear today but groupings of current states into larger "states". Such as the region of the Northeast (Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Rhode Island and so on perhaps even upstate New York, parts of Pennsylvania, forming one regional state.)

I do not think with our current fiscal problems and some truly philosophical differences that we can maintain a strong federal government unless some changes and partisan compromises are achieved.

This will take time but at our current rate I believe we will definately see it within the next generation. If not the breakup at least a severe restructuring of the current US. I donot believe our grandchildren will raise their children in a country recognizeable to us at this present time.

__________________
I just love people who use the excuse "I use/do this because I LOVE the feeling/joy/happiness it brings me" and expect you to be ok with that as you watch them destroy their life blindly following. My response is, "I like to put forks in an eletrical socket, just LOVE that feeling, can't ever get enough of it, so will you let me put this copper fork in that electric socket?"

host

It makes economic sense for the Blue states to secede. As it happens, almost
to a state, the Red states are parasitic in economic terms.
Link to photos below: <a href="http://www.makethemaccountable.com/misc/Maps.htm">http://www.makethemaccountable.com/misc/Maps.htm</a>
<center><img src="http://me.to/svr014.gif">
<img src="http://me.to/svr013.gif"></center>

fastom

Cool, i won't have to cross the border to get to California anymore

flstf

Another solution would be to move more of the retired people, federal employees, nuclear waste sites, weapons test sites, federal prisons, military bases, national parks etc..to the giver states so they could take more of the government's largess.

daswig

Y'all feel free to seceed. It's been tried before, and y'all will NOT like the results if you do.

Bill O'Rights

Based on his repeated use of the term "y'all", daswig might have an inside track there.

Didn't we settle this nonsense about 139 years ago. Secession = not so much a good idea.

__________________
"I distrust those people who know so well what God wants them to do because I notice it always coincides with their own desires." - Susan B. Anthony

"Hedonism with rules isn't hedonism at all, it's the Republican party." - JumpinJesus

It is indisputable that true beauty lies within...but a nice rack sure doesn't hurt.

smooth

you are very confused.

recheck your facts on where retired people, prisons, federal employees, national parks, and military bases are located.


oops, at the risk of seeing some weird post listing all the places just recognize that these are located all over the damn place. in fact, there isn't much room to stuff anything like you listed in california or it'd happen

__________________
"The theory of a free press is that truth will emerge from free discussion, not that it will be presented perfectly and instantly in any one account." -- Walter Lippmann

"You measure democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists." -- Abbie Hoffman

SecretMethod70

I think it's a lot more reasonable today than it was then. Look at Quebec. Canada doesn't threaten war every time they try to declare independence, they just laugh as the majority of people shoot the idea down.

__________________
Le temps détruit tout

"Musicians are the carriers and communicators of spirit in the most immediate sense." - Kurt Elling

fuzyfuzer

for secesion to work the seceding states would have to work together, that would never happen. we wouldn't have to fight an actual war to bring them back. we hold enough power that the US would ban imports from california and we would use our muscle to force our allies into doing the same. slowely we would starve them to death and we would come out victorious. don't get me wrong i would love to see secesion. i would be the first in line to try and make a country the way i would want it to be. without so many people with different views great things could happen in my eyes. the pure ecenomic powerhouse i would build would be unrivaled. i guess i am one of the people that everyone really needs to be affraid of.

__________________
"The difference between commiment and involvment is like a ham and egg breakfast the chicken was involved but the pig was commited"

"Thrice happy is the nation that has a glorious history. Far better it is to dare mighty things, to win glorious triumphs, even though checkered by failure, than to take rank with those poor spirits who neither enjoy much nor suffer much, because they live in the gray twilight that knows neither victory nor defeat." Theodore Roosevelt

Manx

The illusory appeal of dictatorship.

djtestudo

Just a couple observations on some of the posts I read.

Host, I don't trust a map that marks DC, but can't put it anywhere near where it really is

Pan, that was basically how this nation started. Under the Articles of Confederation each state was essentially it's own nation, allied with the others for common defense and foreign affairs. That failed, so the leaders created the Constitution.

Now, those were different times, so with the way the economies work now that may be a somewhat viable outcome, but I can't see it working.

Bingle, it's very simple. If a state were to seceed, it would be invaded and brought back into the US unless it could fight off the US military. A state like Maine wouldn't be particularly hard to bring back, unless it joined with Canada or something like in Halx's map.

__________________
"Final thought: I just rented Michael Moore's Bowling for Columbine. Frankly, it was the worst sports movie I've ever seen."
--Peter Schmuck, The (Baltimore) Sun

Konichiwaneko

I think there's a map on hannity.com that shows it's mostly the inner cities that vote liberal. I wouldn't mind seeing cities seceed, that would lead to some interesting stuff.

found it



I remember when I used to be a liberal, ah nostalgia...life was good when you could blame all your problems on someone else.

__________________

djtestudo

Amazing that Democrats can only really win the far Northeast, NYC, Philly, Baltimore/DC, Miami, Chicago, LA, SF Bay area, Seattle, and parts of the northern and southern Mississippi Valley, and have the power they do.

__________________
"Final thought: I just rented Michael Moore's Bowling for Columbine. Frankly, it was the worst sports movie I've ever seen."
--Peter Schmuck, The (Baltimore) Sun

Konichiwaneko

it's what you get when people scramble to the inner cities to gamble for a chance of a dream job, only to find a majority of them will have minimum wage or unemployment. This results in a flux of people seeking government help more and more, which the democrats are more likely to endorse.

I like helping people, but a majority of those programs breed dependency and thus leading to more and more social programs, which ultimately cripple the future of or society and people. I believe that's what leads to the majority democratic vote.

__________________

Ilow

Because of recent events (not just the election, but the cultural divide that resulted in the election's results), what might have been an almost inconcievable notion twenty, ten, or even five years ago suddenly seems worthy of some consideration. The Civil War forced two vastly disparate groups of states together into what once was the most powerful nation in the world. However, almost 140 years later, we hold a tremendous national debt, have a military stretched perilously thinly across the globe, will have insufficient funding for social services such as Social Security or Welfare in the near future, and are regarded as a nation of religious fanatics by large portions of the globe. I doubt that this is the great nation that the well-intentioned President Lincoln desired. In retrospect, perhaps we would have been better advised not to have sent millions of citizens to their deaths in order to retain a group of states who did not want to be.
With regard to the situation today, it is my impression that the vast majority of people who debate secession are doing so because they do not wish to share a country with people who have values and beliefs that are almost unrecognizable to them. Further, the "blue" state people also seem to generally believe that the "red" state people would be just as happy with out them as well. If I were in charge of dividing the United States into groups of secceding nations, I would likely divide the country into four (not two) segments, something like: "the west" including the pacific coast states, Nevada, and possible Arizona and New Mexico, "the northeast" including New England, New York, Pennsylvania Ohio (for contiguity) Mighigan, Minnesota, etc. (Illinois may have to be left in the cold, unless you could convert Indiana). You could then divide the "red south" into two portions (to prevent unweildyness), say east and west of the Mississippi, or something. I haven't really thought this out too much, but I do feel that if things get too bad, then I may consider it as a plausible option.

__________________
"Religion is the one area of our discourse in which it is considered noble to pretend to be certain about things no human being could possibly be certain about"
--Sam Harris

smooth

yeah, and we can form an alliance with the East Coasters:

NALE -- North American Liberal Elites

that'd be dope

__________________
"The theory of a free press is that truth will emerge from free discussion, not that it will be presented perfectly and instantly in any one account." -- Walter Lippmann

"You measure democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists." -- Abbie Hoffman

Ilow

yeah, can't forget NJ, DE, MD and DC!

__________________
"Religion is the one area of our discourse in which it is considered noble to pretend to be certain about things no human being could possibly be certain about"
--Sam Harris

Dyze

Strange, the people in the cities that are most likely to get hit by a terrorist attack voted for Kerry. They know who makes their homes safer.

__________________
Knowing is not enough, we must apply.
Willing is not enough, we must do.

fuzyfuzer

ya because the only reason any one voted for Kerry was because he was gonna make us safer it couldn't have anything to do with their money situation

__________________
"The difference between commiment and involvment is like a ham and egg breakfast the chicken was involved but the pig was commited"

"Thrice happy is the nation that has a glorious history. Far better it is to dare mighty things, to win glorious triumphs, even though checkered by failure, than to take rank with those poor spirits who neither enjoy much nor suffer much, because they live in the gray twilight that knows neither victory nor defeat." Theodore Roosevelt

alpha phi

The blue areas aren't simply the big cities.
They are the indrustrial centers
The polling results said 60% of the people who voted Kerry
voted againt Bush, not because they liked Kerry
Mostly because of job loss and war
To bad they didn't just vote Badnarik
leaving the union wouldn't be good
a revolution is better at the ballot box(just slower)

__________________

bingle

On the contrary - I think it would be impossible, politically, for the US to invade Maine - all the more so because it would be such a one-sided battle.

The government can barely get a majority of support to invade Iraq - there's no way they would get popular support for the invasion of part of our own country. They would definitely use all sorts of political pressure to avoid the secession, but I don't think invasion would be a viable option in the case of Maine.

Also, even though it's true that it's mostly urban areas that vote democratic (and it looks mighty impressive to compare square footage of red and blue areas - if acreage could vote, you'd have a winner) if you look at the results of the popular vote for the last election, it's not that overwhelming of a landslide.

Note that I'm not necessarily pushing for secession - as I said, unless something major changes, I don't think people really want that. I just think it's interesting to consider in the context of modern times - I think it would be almost impossible to have a civil war now, unless it started as an armed insurrection. However, it would be equally impossible for the US to let a state leave...

Bingle

adam

While I don't think succession is a particularly good idea, I think it is silly to assume it would be settled in military terms. Presuming succession were really popular enough in the states in question, a campaign of non-violent resistence would be pretty tough for the remaining states to squelch. All California has to do is refuse to pay tax revenues to have a big effect on the U.S. Any really widespread civil disobediance that was actually supported by the corresponding state governments would be impossible for the U.S. military to control -- we don't have enough troops for that. And killing people for tax evasion isn't going to happen unless the rest of the U.S. has really embraced fascism.

JJRousseau

So looking at the county vote, it doesn't look like we (Canada) get California, Oregon and Washington after all. Just everything west of the I-5. Cool. Leave the guns at home. Bring the wine! Halx, you'd love Yaletown. It's our up and coming internet/video game/e-commerce neighbourhood.

Ustwo

Its the same country on Nov 2 as it is today.

You get your shot again in 2 years to turn the tables.

Until then the people have spoken. The same people that voted for Carter and Clinton.

__________________
Agents of the enemies who hold office in our own government, who attempt to eliminate our "freedoms" and our "right to know" are posting among us, I fear.....on this very forum. - host

Obama - Know a Man by the friends he keeps.

drawerfixer

I can't seem to find the best maps that I've seen over the past few days, but here is one pretty good one.

Tophat665

Now don't take this the wrong way, big guy, But Gary Bauer and Ralph Reed were not turning out their legions of deluded Jesus Freaks (TM) for Clinton or Carter.

<i>A digression</I>
A note to the Christians on the board: by Jesus Freak, I mean a person who 1) calls himself Christian, and 2) finds Leviticus more relevant than the gospels, preventing one's neighbor from sinning more important than loving him, and/or actively works to bring about Revelations. These people are dangerous madmen. (And their women are equally dangerous.)

I do not believe there are any here who answer that description.
<i>We now return you to your regularly scheduled thread already in progress.</i>

__________________
Light a man a fire, and he will be warm while it burns.
Set a man on fire, and he will be warm for the rest of his life.

smooth

yeah, occasionally one of them figures out how to cross the damn thing and clutters up our beaches. But we just show them the polluted signs and they wander back to their cow fields, mumbling some shit or other about city foke.

__________________
"The theory of a free press is that truth will emerge from free discussion, not that it will be presented perfectly and instantly in any one account." -- Walter Lippmann

"You measure democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists." -- Abbie Hoffman

Ustwo

If you think this election was all about 'jesus freaks' who won it for Bush then you are ignoring most of the people who voted for him.

The moral issue concept is more of an excuse than a reality, even slate.com admits as much and there editorials are on par with democraticunderground.com.

Terrorism is why Kerry lost this election.

__________________
Agents of the enemies who hold office in our own government, who attempt to eliminate our "freedoms" and our "right to know" are posting among us, I fear.....on this very forum. - host

Obama - Know a Man by the friends he keeps.

Charlatan

Tell you what... as much as I'd hate to see it go, the US can have Alberta and we'll take California,Washington, Oregon and the Northeast...

There's a lot of oil in Alberta... more than what the Saudi's have...


(then again, we already sold it all to the US when Mulroney signed the FTA...)

__________________
"My hands are on fire. Hands are on fire. Ain't got no more time for all you charlatans and liars."
- Old Man Luedecke

cbr9racr

LOL...california can leave the union...it would be a blessing. The only think we'd miss would be silicon valley...the rest can fall in the ocean for all I care.

Tophat665

Well... maybe. I would say that Bush's support came from people who think that he will be good for business, and, as you say, people who he has scared the bejesus out of who think against all evidence that he is competetant as a fighter of terrorism. That is the bulk of his vote. Turning out the nutjobs, so they will maintain, is what put him over the top, though. This may or may not be true, but, much like Revelations, the Jesus Freaks will insist it is, and it's the thought that counts. That's the problem, he is beholden to them (not that he wasn't already, buty now he gets to frame it in terms of payback.)

And what the heck is it with a Mandate? 51% is a pretty feeble mandate. More of a Boydate. Sure he got more votes than any other president. John Kerry lost with the most votes ever. That a lot of people turned out is irrelevant to the calculation that only slightly more (and at the numbers we're discussing, 3 million is not that big) support that the other fellow, and once again, half the country is screwed to the point where we have a semi serious thread about secession (a nice idea, but a silly one.)

__________________
Light a man a fire, and he will be warm while it burns.
Set a man on fire, and he will be warm for the rest of his life.

Konichiwaneko

...clinton didnt eventop 50% guys

Historically a 5 point difference is a definite win in the Presidential Election. What's with the 51% rhetoric...No president has gotten above that in 20 years.

__________________

guy44

Yeah, all the Dems can win are almost 50% of the populace. Amazing they have the power they do.

Here's the thing; all those red areas are so amazingly underpopulated. I mean, damn near desolate. So while all that red may look real good or bad, depending on your outlook, the fact is that this country is still split almost 50/50.

I mean, if you just want to talk geographic size, Alaska is half the size of the continental United States, and red, but has less people than on tiny part of my home town, Chicago.

And secession nowadays is a silly idea. What SHOULD have happened is Lincoln could have told the South that they could seceed as long as they let blacks and Native Americans leave first. Then the U.S. could have developed without the money drain of the South...yeah, thats the ticket. I am being mildly facetious, of course. Mildly.

__________________
"You have reached Ritual Sacrifice. For goats press one, or say 'goats.'"

Konichiwaneko

Lol I know you are being facitious but I'll comment on this.

For people who think that the Metroplii is where all the money is, please be aware that yes a larger concentration of wealth is from there, but the raw resources used to accumulate that wealth, the actual tangibles are from the scarcely populated area. The business owners, and the workers share a mutual relationship when it comes to that. Most jobs inside the city are "Decadence jobs" those that aren't required if lets say, a nuclear strike occurred. So respect your farmers, and rural folks, they are the foundation to our society.

__________________