hannukah harry,
As illustrated before we can either have rocks that no being can lift or a being that can lift any rock. Either one or the other but never both. If one exists it automatically cancels out the existence of the other.
You say that we are just talking about mass and strength, that there is nothing complicated about these qualities. Well there is nothing complicated about a square and a circle but no shape can poses both qualities. Omnipotence and immovability are not qualities of a god or a rock, but rather qualities of the universe. The universe either has omnipotent beings or immovable rocks; it can never possess both for it would be a contradiction.
|