|
Harry,
You admit then that a triangular circle is a logical impossibility.
Nano's analogy is not comparing apples to oranges.
The essential nature of a square is that it has four sides, all angles are 90 degrees etc. A triangle has only three sides, therefore a triangular square cannot exist since it would not fulfill the essential requirements of being either a square or a triangle.
God is omipotent, therefore there is nothing too heavy for God to lift.
You are asking if God could create a stone which is too heavy for God (for whom there is nothing too heavy to lift). Therefore the stone contradicts the nature of God's omnipotence.
It is more accurate to say that such a stone cannot exist rather than God cannot create it.
|