Er...no. They say the same thing.
BBC site says:
And although the sci-fi sect was not officially listed as a religion, collators did include a special code to register the Jedis.
Snopes quotes a spokesperson:
"Because a certain number of people were likely to have put Jedi Knight as a response to that question, it has been included as a code simply to help speed the forms through the machine-readers," a spokesman for the Office of National Statistics told Reuters.
"All that will happen is that it will be recorded as 'Other'," he said. "It certainly does not mean it is recognized as a religion."
So they don't disagree at all.