Well, if everyone wants to debate the topic, try doing so in a forum that has people a lot more experienced than I am.
Atkins Diet Bulletin Board
You'll probably never agree with anyone there, but at least you'll hear from people who have been doing it longer, have been engaged in the testing you recommend, and are equally adept at posting links to articles on Atkins. By the way, that link to the Atkins Diet Alert sight is sponsored by PETA.