Batman: Arkham Asylum
Good: Superb graphics, you
are the Batman
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc690/cc690967aeee6262751214bb97f6d99f62e16dc8" alt="Wink"
, challenges/Riddler challenges add replay value, combat is simple yet rewarding and fucking gorgeous.
Bad: Length is short (about 10 hours or so on normal), boss fights are underwhelming, more villains could've been used.
I got Batman from GameFly this Monday and I have to say I'm impressed. This is
the definitive Batman game. If you're a Batman fan and you don't play this game, you're doing yourself a disservice. Hopefully they'll bring in some villains via DLC since that's what every developer seems to be doing this generation.