Quote:
Originally Posted by Katyanna
As you have said it is a religious belief. Halx does not subscribe to this religious belief, so the point of what it says in the Torah (I assume) is moot to him. I mean this in the most respectful way to you Xazy, I do not mean this to insult your personal beliefs.
|
I do not care if he considers himself Jewish or not that is his choice. Other Jews and I will consider him Jewish. I never go around saying you are Jewish or force my belief on anyone at all, but that does not change from a Jewish stand point that if your mother is Jewish you are consider a Jew. I do not care what you believe and do that is between you and G-d not my place to judge. But the point I made as well is this belief is not something new for Jews, this is the Jewish belief and is documented for over 2000 years and comments in the Torah itself lead to it (which makes the origination of the belief way back when).