Herk, no one has mentioned criminal actions being taken, so it's like you still aren't aware of the argument at hand.
Quote:
|
Extreme circumstances are the only circumstances that belong being compared. They make clear the blunders in logic.
|
Not when the extreme circumstance being used has nothing to do with the conversation at hand. Destroying a countries economy by hacking records is just a wee bit different than downloading copyrighted materials, and the charges for such would differ greatly.
Quote:
|
Not wacky at all. What is wacky is assuming this makes you criminally responsible for all actions on your account.
|
Criminally responsible, no, responsible for action on your account, you sure are.
Quote:
|
Yes, they have proof that the download happened through your account, nobody is arguing that. What they don't have proof of, is that YOU downloaded that material using your account. So, losses incurred are your responsibility, but criminally you still need to prove that I broke the law.
|
So they have proof that the download happened through your account, which YOU are responsible for, so they now have proof YOU did it.