Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community - View Single Post

Borla · 01-16-2008, 06:05 PM

He's not the most skilled ever.
He's not the smartest ever.
He doesn't have the best arm ever.
He's not the most successful ever.

But he's high enough in all of those catagories to be in any discussion of the best QB ever. IMO, he's thrown too many interceptions, and too many incompletions, and made too many throws off his back foot into coverage trying to force a play.

But I can't argue against him being one of the most fun to watch ever, one of the ones to love the game most, and one of the guys I'd most want to build around ever. Names like Montana, Starr, Brady, Manning, etc. might be in that conversation too. Maybe Peyton is better. Maybe Joe was better. Maybe even Dan was better, but had a lesser cast surrounding him. But we all benefited by having the pleasure of watching #4 go out there every Sunday and give it his best, no doubt about that.

<---Not a Packers fan.

01-16-2008, 06:05 PM	#30 (permalink)
Borla Junkie	He's not the most skilled ever. He's not the smartest ever. He doesn't have the best arm ever. He's not the most successful ever. But he's high enough in all of those catagories to be in any discussion of the best QB ever. IMO, he's thrown too many interceptions, and too many incompletions, and made too many throws off his back foot into coverage trying to force a play. But I can't argue against him being one of the most fun to watch ever, one of the ones to love the game most, and one of the guys I'd most want to build around ever. Names like Montana, Starr, Brady, Manning, etc. might be in that conversation too. Maybe Peyton is better. Maybe Joe was better. Maybe even Dan was better, but had a lesser cast surrounding him. But we all benefited by having the pleasure of watching #4 go out there every Sunday and give it his best, no doubt about that. <---Not a Packers fan. __________________ Coimhéad fearg fhear na foighde!!!!