Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Luke Cage
(Only voting the qb's I have actually seen play in my lifetime)
1. Joe Montana
2. Dan Marino
3. John Elway
4. Peyton Manning / Tom Brady
5. Brett Farve
6. Dan Fouts
7. Warren Moon
8 Jim Kelly
9. Bernie Kosar
10. Theisman, Cunningham (late 80's early 90's).
If I were to make an all-time list... Farve would be in the lower half of the top ten.
|
No doubt this is great list of quarterbacks. However, Brett Favre does not belong at number 5. He has the two most prestigious quarterback records, both of which he is going to continue to build on over the course of next year (which he committed to last week) and however long he decides to play. With no disrespect to Elway, Marino, Manning, Brady, or Montana; Favre surpasses them all. He's got the all around game, and has the numbers to prove it. The only person that could stand in his way is Montana. This is all coming from a die hard, life long Bears fan mind you, so it is hard to admit. But he is the best, and that's the truth.