Yakk hit the nail on the head. These situations only take face value into account. They only seem paradoxal because they arn't real situations. We don't live in theory.
One thing I'm curious about though, in scen 2 why did you give the option to kill the guy with the broken finger, what does he have to do with it?...why wouldn't you give the option to kill one of the ones already dying? Since you said none of the dying patients had the same failed organs.
|