Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community - View Single Post

Beatlefan58 · 10-14-2004, 01:01 PM

Voting to continue until at least 8:00 PM, CDT, October 19, 2004. Directions on voting below.

1. REVOLVER
16. LIVE AT THE BBC

8. LET IT BE
9 PAST MASTERS 2

5. ABBEY ROAD
12. PLEASE PLEASE ME

4. THE BEATLES (The White Album)
13. WITH THE BEATLES

3. RUBBER SOUL
14. PAST MASTERS 1

6. MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR
11. HELP!

7. A HARD DAY'S NIGHT
10. BEATLES FOR SALE

2. SGT. PEPPER
15. YELLOW SUBMARINE

What is this: A tournament of Beatle songs, seeded like a tennis tournament or the NCAA basketball tournament in the USA. Pick a winner in each of the 8 matches. I'll tally the votes and the winners advance.

How to vote: Simpliest way is to cut and paste. For ease of counting, I prefer the numbers be left by the name of the album.

How it was seeded: I put what are often cited as the best Beatle albums in the top four slots, but with this group, even the next three slots were of high quality. I put the 13 original albums, then included LIVE AT THE BBC and the two PAST MASTERS albums as a way to round out the field.

Discussions of the choices are encouraged, but again for ease of counting, I request that the "ballot" be at the top of the page, and the comments below.

Thanks to all that want to take part!

10-14-2004, 01:01 PM	#1 (permalink)
Beatlefan58 Banned	Beatles Album Tournament Voting to continue until at least 8:00 PM, CDT, October 19, 2004. Directions on voting below. 1. REVOLVER 16. LIVE AT THE BBC 8. LET IT BE 9 PAST MASTERS 2 5. ABBEY ROAD 12. PLEASE PLEASE ME 4. THE BEATLES (The White Album) 13. WITH THE BEATLES 3. RUBBER SOUL 14. PAST MASTERS 1 6. MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR 11. HELP! 7. A HARD DAY'S NIGHT 10. BEATLES FOR SALE 2. SGT. PEPPER 15. YELLOW SUBMARINE What is this: A tournament of Beatle songs, seeded like a tennis tournament or the NCAA basketball tournament in the USA. Pick a winner in each of the 8 matches. I'll tally the votes and the winners advance. How to vote: Simpliest way is to cut and paste. For ease of counting, I prefer the numbers be left by the name of the album. How it was seeded: I put what are often cited as the best Beatle albums in the top four slots, but with this group, even the next three slots were of high quality. I put the 13 original albums, then included LIVE AT THE BBC and the two PAST MASTERS albums as a way to round out the field. Discussions of the choices are encouraged, but again for ease of counting, I request that the "ballot" be at the top of the page, and the comments below. Thanks to all that want to take part!