Originally Posted by Rlyss

Scarface - since it's a hypothetical situation I think we can cross out the possibility that the woman behind Door #1 is out to screw up your life. Of course, I'm not saying your choice in Door #2 is wrong at all

As lots of others have said, if I loved the woman behind Door #1 as much as she loved me (and it was genuine, not magic, or a spell or anything like that), then I'd choose #1 without a second thought.

But if it's artificial, if she's a robot or something, or if I don't love her, then I'd choose Door #2. In my life at the moment I'd rather have someone I loved instead of someone who loved me (if they were my only choices) so if the love wasn't genuine and mutual, then Door #2 for me, thanks.