Quote:
|
Originally Posted by warrrreagl
I love this show and have seen every episode, BUT I have a huge problem with the way people are voted off. As you mentioned, the show should be renamed "Interactor" instead of "Survivor." This is the same reason "The Weakest Link" failed so badly; they always voted off the strongest players instead of the weakest players, and the show always ended with mediocre slugs playing for all the money. Survivor works the same way.
There should be individual immunity available to certain people going to tribal council who have proven that they deserve to stay and not get blind-sided. That comes into play when the tribes merge, but it should be available at the beginning, too.
|
I said something similar in the Survivor Pearl Islands thread (I believe).
I stated that through that season (7 seasons), only 3 of the 7 winners actually deserved to win:
Survivor 1: Richard
Survivor 3: Ethan
Survivor 5: Brian
The others won by being mediocre:
Survivor 2: Tina
Survivor 4: Vecepia
Survivor 6: Jenna
Survivor 7: Sandra
I think Rob should have won Survivor All Stars, but an argument could be made for Amber.
Interesting how it splits straight down the gender line, eh?