Quote:
Originally posted by losthellhound
I think my only problem with the locking of threads is the timing. I know its hard to keep track of whats happening, but it seems that alot of name calling, alot of trash talking happens before a moderator steps in and calms people down. Ive noticed that they dont have to lock threads, just be there and make a comment to calm it down. Most of the time.
I'd guess you just need more moderators.. Shouldnt be too hard to find, if thats the way you go..
|
Well, not really, that’s why we have that nifty “report this post to a moderator” link on every post- so that you can alert us when things like that happen. The amount of moderators necessary to cover EVERY forum and EVERY post in every thread ALL the time would be staggering, and unnecessary. And sometimes, a flame might be left alone (temporarily) if it’s not all that bad, because you all have (at times) reversed yourselves and kept each other in check.
Quote:
Originally posted by Stare At The Sun
Considering I started a thread about Hitlers GOOD points, and it eventually lead into Holocaust denial, and yet, wasn't locked for some time; I think that is a testament to both the members of this board and the mods.
|
Yeah, no shit. Thanks
Quote:
Originally posted by Strange Famous
My judgement is that the moderators close threads which are based on a political view they do not share. In their opinion, being a communist or a pacifist just means flaming. I think it is a shame, but you cannot have a real political discussion if only certain voices are permitted to speak.
|
Well, first of all, that’s simply not true, and a fair bit insulting to say the least. To be honest, many political “party” terms mean nothing to me, as I have no idea what they stand for on all the issues- as many of you do/think you do.
Second, I closed 4* of your 5 closed threads (as listed by Lebell) myself, and I have
no political affiliation whatsoever. I HATE politics. I hate talking politics, I don’t like to read about politics, and I am in no way active on any real issue. I have my own beliefs, but I don’t assert them in any real politically tangible way. If you’ll notice, I
rarely, if ever, post my own non-official-mod-stuff posts in Tilted Politics- and when I do, it’s usually just because something peeved me enough to make me want to weight in with my $0.02.
The 1* thread not closed by myself was closed after, in my opinion, all hope was lost. I’d also have closed it- and maybe a few posts sooner.
Quote:
Originally posted by mml
Funny this thread came along. I have noticed how many threads have been locked and for the most part, it has been a blessing. However, on SF's "murder is murder" thread the whole thing was quashed after 12 posts!? Now, I totally disagree with SF, but he has his opinion, and it deserves more than 12 rebutals. Hell, I started a lame "do you lean to the left or right" thread and it is still going. Just my opinion, but it seems like the mods are cracking down a littel too quickly.
The politics threads are a mess, just like actual politics, but I dislike censorship in any form.
|
I
HATE censorship in any form.
Only problem is, WarWagon said it very well already:
Quote:
Originally posted by WarWagon
I just give the mods even more credit for catching it ahead of time. That thread was GUARANTEED to get out of hand. Hell, I wish there was a way for me to "block" all of Tilted Politics as of late.
|
I couldn’t have said it better, because it wouldn’t weigh as heavily coming from my name.
Considering that:
1. The thread starter already had 4
other posts started by him go
very very sour due to the way the topic and subject matter was presented and perpetuated, and
2. They always went downhill in much the same fashion- always degrading into a volley of flaming and trolling,
I do not think it is unreasonable for me to say that- even if I couldn’t normally see it coming- It was blindingly obvious in this case, based on past threads of that nature.
Also, I might mention in my own defense (but more just to offer explanation, I have no reason to defend it) that his argument was
largely speculation and opinion, with little to back up his very controversial, damaging, and politically white-hot assertions.
Closing that thread was an easy decision, and an obvious necessity. I apologize to those who feel they may have had something of value to contribute- I was not trying to censor you, and I think most of you know this. Had it been phrased differently (better, not as a troll) and had it more factual information or sources to back it up, it’d still be open (most likely) and up for discussion.
Thanks for reading.
-analog.
*EDIT:
Quote:
Originally posted by Lebell
-Is Ann Coulter the most vile person in America? Total posts: 47 Locked by: MrSelfDestruct
|
That's actually not true-
I closed that thread as well, MrSelfDestruct accidentally posted to it afterwards, making it 4 of his 5 threads I closed.